Trustpilot
Loading...
Loading...Loading...
I was helping my neighbor calculate what she could actually afford for her first home, and when we got to the part about ongoing costs beyond the mortgage, her jaw literally dropped. She'd saved up this amazing down payment, had her mortgage preapproval all ready to go—but had absolutely no idea about the hidden expenses that come with owning a home. And honestly? She's not alone. According to the U.S. Census Bureau's 2024 American Community Survey, median monthly owner costs for homeowners with a mortgage reached $2,035 in 2024, and that doesn't even tell the whole story.
Think of it like this: buying a home is kind of like adopting a pet that costs hundreds of thousands of dollars. You're not just paying for the initial adoption fee (down payment), you're signing up for ongoing care that never really stops. And just like nobody warns you how expensive vet bills can get, a lot of first-time buyers don't realize the true financial commitment they're making.
When we acquired our current process system, I remember sitting through training sessions where they'd talk about "total cost of ownership." That phrase stuck with me because it applies perfectly to homes. You're not just buying a house—you're buying into a whole ecosystem of expenses.
Your down payment typically ranges from 3% to 20% of the purchase price, depending on your loan type. For conventional loans, putting down less than 20% means you'll need private mortgage insurance (PMI), which typically costs 0.4% to 1.5% of the original loan amount annually. On a $400,000 loan, that's an extra $1,600 to $6,000 per year until you reach 20% equity.
FHA loans allow down payments as low as 3.5%, but they come with both upfront and ongoing mortgage insurance premiums. VA loans offer zero-down options for eligible veterans, while USDA loans provide similar benefits for rural property buyers. The point is, you've got options—but each choice has different long-term cost implications.
Closing costs hit hard, typically running 2% to 5% of your home's purchase price. On a $437,942 home (the median price as of April 2025 according to Redfin as cited by Bankrate), you're looking at $8,759 to $21,897 just to get the keys.
Some of these costs can be negotiated—asking the seller to cover closing costs is pretty common in buyer-friendly markets. But you need to budget for them either way.
Your mortgage payment isn't just about paying back what you borrowed. Most lenders require you to escrow property taxes and homeowners insurance, meaning these costs get rolled into your monthly payment. This is where people get surprised.
Here's what a typical monthly payment actually includes:
Principal and Interest: This is the part that pays down your loan balance and covers the lender's interest charges. On a 30-year fixed mortgage at current rates, you're paying mostly interest in the early years.
Property Taxes: These vary wildly depending on where you live. According to the Tax Foundation's 2025 Property Tax Maps, effective property tax rates range from 0.27% in Hawaii to 2.23% in New Jersey. For a $400,000 home, that's the difference between $1,080 and $8,920 annually.
Homeowners Insurance: Insurance costs have absolutely exploded lately. The Zebra's July 2025 report shows the national average hitting $2,802 per year, but some states like Nebraska ($7,920) and Oklahoma ($7,426) pay nearly three times that amount. And premiums are rising 8.7% faster than inflation.
PMI (if applicable): If you put down less than 20%, add this to your monthly nut until you hit that equity threshold.
Property taxes are probably the most underestimated ongoing cost. In my MSW program, we talked a lot about how financial stress compounds when people don't plan for variable expenses, and property taxes are a perfect example because they can increase over time.
According to Bankrate's 2025 Hidden Costs of Homeownership Study, hidden costs beyond your mortgage average $21,400 annually nationwide. Property taxes make up a huge chunk of that figure.
Here's what most people don't realize: property taxes aren't fixed. As home values increase (which they've been doing—median home prices jumped from $303,400 in 2020 to $437,942 by April 2025), your tax bill likely increases too. Some states reassess annually, while others do it when properties change hands or undergo major renovations. And here's the kicker—26% of first-time homeowners didn't realize property taxes fluctuate over time.
The median property tax bill nationwide hit $3,500 in 2024. But in states like New Jersey, you're paying a median of $9,413 annually, while West Virginia homeowners pay just $728. Location matters enormously.
Okay, insurance is where I really need to be straight with you—this market has gone absolutely bonkers. Single-family homeowners with mortgages now pay an average of $2,370 annually according to ICE Mortgage Technology data. That's a 70% increase since 2021.
Why the surge? Climate change is making natural disasters more frequent and severe. Construction costs are up. Materials are expensive. Labor is scarce. Insurify projects the national average will hit $3,520 by the end of 2025, an 8% jump from 2024.
And Florida? It already has the highest premiums in the country, with rates expected to reach $15,460 annually by end of 2025. Some cities like Hialeah, Florida are projected to hit $26,693.
The scariest part is that nearly 60% of homeowners surveyed said they might forgo coverage if it becomes too expensive. That's terrifying from a financial planning perspective—going without insurance could be financially catastrophic if disaster strikes.
If you buy in a community with a homeowners association, budget an average of $125 monthly according to the source data, though this varies dramatically. Some HOAs charge $50 a month, others charge $500+. In condo buildings, HOA fees can run into the thousands because they cover building maintenance, insurance, amenities, and sometimes utilities.
I've seen buyers get blindsided by special assessments for roof replacements or parking lot repaving. These can run thousands of dollars and come with very little notice.
The average monthly cost for utilities runs about $430 according to the source article, but this varies based on:
First-time buyers coming from apartments often underestimate utility costs because they've never paid for heating/cooling an entire house, or they've had water/sewer included in rent.
Here's where we get into the expenses that really catch people off guard. The standard advice is to budget 1% of your home's value annually for maintenance. Real Estate Witch's 2025 data shows homeowners actually pay an average of $24,529 per year in costs beyond their mortgage—that includes utilities, repairs, maintenance, property taxes, and insurance.
Thumbtack's 2024 Home Care Price Index found home maintenance costs averaged $6,543.50 in 2023. And Bankrate's study estimates maintenance at 2% of median home value for their calculations.
Here's the thing: maintenance isn't optional. It's preventative medicine for your biggest investment. Skip it, and you'll pay way more later. Think about:
Then there are the surprise expenses. Hot water heater goes out? $1,000-3,000. Roof needs replacing? $8,000-20,000 depending on size and materials. Foundation issues? Don't even get me started.
According to American Home Shield's 2025 survey of 1,001 homeowners, the first year of homeownership can cost $86,698 when you add up:
And here's the brutal truth: 46% of first-time buyers didn't understand the true cost before purchasing. Nearly 1 in 4 (24%) didn't budget for closing fees. Over 40% had no furnishing budget, and 56% didn't budget for repairs.
And get this—81% of homeowners say costs are higher than expected according to Real Estate Witch. Nearly half (44%) believe it's easier to be a renter than a homeowner.
That last one is crucial. You need reserves beyond your down payment and closing costs. Stuff breaks, sometimes expensively and at the worst possible moment.
AmeriSave has different loan programs that work with different down payment amounts when you're ready to look into your mortgage options. If you're a veteran, you might want to look into VA loans. If you're not a veteran, you might want to look into conventional loans or FHA loans that don't require a large down payment. The right financing structure can make a big difference in how much you pay each month. Knowing what your options are will help you plan for all the costs we've talked about.
AmeriSave also has mortgage calculators and other tools to help you figure out your real monthly payment, which includes taxes and insurance as well as principal and interest. This clearer picture of the total cost of housing will help you plan your budget better.
Owning a home costs a lot of money. Like, even after reading this article, it's more expensive than you think. However, if you look at it with open eyes, it is also one of the best ways to build wealth.
Planning for ALL of your costs, not just the ones that show up in your mortgage payment, is the key. Plan your budget carefully, keep an emergency fund, and don't put yourself in a position where one unexpected expense could ruin your finances.
In other words, before you fall in love with a house, make sure you love a budget that includes all of the costs we've talked about. Do the math. Put in a buffer. Then figure out what you can really afford.
It's not just what you pay for a house that matters; it's also being ready for what you'll pay.
You should plan for more than just your mortgage payment. You should also plan for property taxes, homeowners insurance, maintenance, utilities, and possibly HOA fees and PMI. Bankrate's 2025 study found that these hidden costs add up to an average of $21,400 a year across the country, but this varies a lot by location. Depending on where you live, property taxes can be as low as 0.4% or as high as 2% of the value of your home. Homeowners insurance costs between $2,800 and $3,500 a year on average, but in states with a lot of risk, they can cost more than $7,000. Every year, maintenance costs about 1% to 2% of the value of your home. The Census Bureau says that in 2024, the median monthly costs for homeowners with mortgages were $2,035. To be safe, set aside an extra $1,500 to $2,000 a month on top of your regular mortgage payment to cover these ongoing costs.
Your down payment and closing costs are examples of upfront costs. Depending on the type of loan you get, your down payment will usually be between 3% and 20% of the purchase price. A 20% down payment on a $437,942 home (the median price in 2025) would be $87,588. Closing costs are an extra 2% to 5% of the purchase price, which is about $8,759 to $21,897 for that same home. These closing costs include the costs of getting an appraisal (about $350), getting a home inspection (between $300 and $400), title insurance, lender fees, attorney fees in some states, and paying property taxes and insurance in advance. You should also set aside money for moving costs, new furniture for your new home, and any repairs or improvements that need to be made right away. American Home Shield's 2025 survey found that the average cost of owning a home in the first year, including the down payment, furniture, and repairs, was $86,698.
Homeowners insurance rates have gone up 70% since 2021 because of a number of things that have come together. Climate change has made hurricanes, wildfires, floods, and hail storms happen more often and with more force. This has led to more claims and higher payouts. Inflation, problems with the supply chain, and tariffs on imported materials like lumber and steel have all made the cost of building materials go up. This makes repairs and rebuilding more expensive. The lack of workers in construction makes costs go up even more. Insurance companies are also paying more for reinsurance, and they pass those costs on to customers. The biggest increases are in states that have a lot of natural disasters. Louisiana's population is expected to grow by 27% by 2025, while California's population is expected to grow by 21% after terrible wildfires. Some insurance companies have stopped writing new policies or left high-risk states altogether. This has made competition less and prices higher in those markets.
According to the Tax Foundation's 2025 data, property tax rates can be very different from state to state. For example, the effective rate in Hawaii is 0.27% and in New Jersey it is 2.23%. That's the difference between paying $1,080 a year in Hawaii and $8,920 a year in New Jersey for a $400,000 home. Illinois (2.08%), Connecticut (1.79%), and New Hampshire (1.93%) also have high rates. Alabama (0.39%), Colorado (0.49%), and Nevada (0.50%) have some of the lowest rates. There are a number of reasons why property taxes can and do go up over time. Tax assessments usually go up when home values go up, even if the rate stays the same. To pay for schools, roads, and other public services, local governments can raise the millage rate. Some states check the value of properties every year, while others only do so when a home sells or gets major repairs. Twenty-six percent of people who bought their first home didn't know that property taxes can change. This can make it hard to stick to a budget when bills go up unexpectedly.
The 1% maintenance rule says that you should set aside 1% of your home's value each year for routine repairs and maintenance. That's $4,000 a year, or about $333 a month, for a $400,000 home. But because the cost of materials and labor is going up, many experts now say to budget 2%. Bankrate uses the 2% number in their calculations, but Thumbtack's real spending data shows that homeowners spent an average of $6,543.50 on maintenance in 2023. The truth is that maintenance costs aren't the same for everyone. Some years you won't spend much at all. In some years, you'll have to pay for big things like replacing your roof, fixing your HVAC system, or getting a new water heater. The age of the house is also important. Older homes with old systems and parts usually need more maintenance than newer homes. The 1% rule is a good starting point, but you should change it based on how old your house is, how well it is kept up, and how much labor costs are in your area. A lot of financial advisors say that you should set up a separate emergency fund just for home repairs that go beyond your regular maintenance budget.
There are a number of ways to lower the overall cost of owning a home. Every year, compare prices for homeowners insurance and think about getting a discount by combining it with auto insurance. If you raise your deductible from $500 to $2,000, you could save an average of $500 a year on premiums. However, you'll need that much money on hand if you need to file a claim. Before you buy, work on your credit score. Better credit means lower interest rates and insurance premiums. Put down a bigger down payment to avoid PMI and lower your mortgage balance. If you think your property tax assessment is too high compared to other homes in your area, you can appeal it. Spend money on preventative maintenance to keep from having to pay for costly emergency repairs. Improvements that save energy, like better insulation, LED lights, and a programmable thermostat, will lower your utility bills over time. If you live in a neighborhood with a HOA, go to meetings and look over the finances to stay up to date on possible special assessments. If you can afford higher payments, think about getting a 15-year mortgage instead of a 30-year one. This will save you a lot of money on interest over the life of the loan. Finally, make sure you have a strong emergency fund so that unexpected costs don't force you to take out high-interest loans.
Even though prices are going up, owning a home is still one of the best ways for most Americans to build wealth. Homeownership has benefits that renting doesn't, even though 81% of homeowners say their costs were higher than they thought and 44% say renting is easier. Instead of paying rent that makes someone else richer, you build equity with each mortgage payment. Real estate usually goes up in value over time, but this depends on the market. With fixed-rate loans, mortgage payments stay pretty stable, but rent usually goes up every year. If you itemize, you can get tax breaks on your mortgage interest and property taxes. You can change, update, and use your property however you want. The most important thing is to be ready for the full cost, not just the mortgage payment. Real Estate Witch's 2025 data shows that homeowners pay an average of $24,529 a year on top of their mortgage, which is almost the same as the average mortgage payment of $26,508 a year. To be successful, you need to stick to a strict budget, have a lot of money saved up for emergencies, and be realistic about how much money you will need to spend each month. Homeownership offers stability, equity growth, and long-term financial advantages that generally surpass those of renting, provided individuals plan effectively.
When it comes to the costs of owning a home, first-time buyers make a lot of expensive mistakes. According to a 2025 survey by American Home Shield, almost half (46%) didn't know the real cost before they bought. Twenty-four percent didn't plan for closing costs, so they had to come up with thousands of dollars at the last minute to pay for them. More than 40% didn't have a budget for furniture because they didn't realize how much it costs to make empty rooms livable. Fifty-six percent didn't set aside money for repairs, so they are at risk when the roof leaks or the hot water heater breaks. Twenty-six percent didn't know that property taxes would go up and down over time. Sixteen percent of people knew about HOA fees but didn't plan for them. If they've only lived in apartments where some utilities were included, a lot of buyers also don't realize how much utilities will cost. Another common mistake is taking all of your savings out for the down payment and closing costs, leaving nothing for emergencies or the surprises that will happen in the first year. First-time buyers also tend to spend all of their money on a house based on how much they can get approved for a mortgage, instead of figuring out how much they can afford with all of their expenses. Lastly, a lot of people skip or don't think a thorough home inspection is important, which means they miss costly problems that come up soon after they buy the house.
The difference between the required income and the actual earnings is a big problem when it comes to affordability. According to Bankrate's 2025 Housing Affordability Study, Americans need a household income of $116,986 or more to comfortably buy a home in today's market. This calculation is based on the common rule that housing costs shouldn't be more than 28% to 30% of gross income. Many families can't afford to buy a home because the median home price is $437,942 and the median monthly cost for homeowners with mortgages is $2,035. IPX1031's 2025 survey found that 47% of Americans can't afford to buy a home. Of those, 51% are Millennials, who should be in their prime home-buying years. The Census Bureau says that the median household income went up in 29 states between 2023 and 2024. However, in many cases, wages have not kept up with the rising cost of housing. According to Census Bureau economist Jacob Fabina, homeowners are spending a median of 21.4% of their income on owner costs, which is a sign of an increased burden. One in three Americans no longer sees homeownership as part of the American Dream because of this affordability crisis. This is a big change in how people think about housing.
The costs of owning a home that aren't obvious vary a lot from state to state, so where you live is a big part of your budget. Hawaii has the highest average hidden costs at $34,573 a year. This is mostly because maintenance costs average $19,642, utilities average $7,871, and property taxes average $4,301. West Virginia has the lowest yearly cost at $12,579, with property taxes at only $1,063 and maintenance costs at about $5,132. Insurance costs for California homeowners are going up quickly, and by 2025 they are expected to go up by 21%. In contrast, states like Nebraska and Oklahoma have insurance premiums that are almost three times the national average, at $7,920 and $7,426, respectively. Property tax rates are very different; for example, people in New Jersey pay 2.23% while people in Hawaii pay 0.27%. Do some research on your state and county to make sure your budget is accurate. Visit your county assessor's website to find out the property tax rates and get real insurance quotes for the address you're thinking about. The cost of utilities depends on the weather, the types of energy used, and the rates in your area. Some states have mild weather that doesn't need as much heating and cooling, while others have extreme temperatures that make utility bills go up. States that are likely to have natural disasters have to pay more for insurance and may have to make more expensive repairs more often.
Fact Checked