Trustpilot
Loading...
Loading...Loading...
So, my husband texted me a listing for this beautiful 1920s bungalow about ten minutes from our home in Louisville while I was looking over a project proposal for our home buyer education series. Well, “beautiful” is a stretch. The pictures showed that paint was peeling, the kitchen looked like it hadn't been updated since 1987, and the carpet was probably from the Reagan administration. But the bones were very robust and the price was around $180,000, which is a good deal for a house that would sell for $280,000 if someone gave it some TLC.
The first thing that came to mind was excitement. But to be honest, my second thought was fear. I've seen enough home improvement projects go wrong to know that the difference between a great deal and a money pit is about the size of a roof leak that you forgot about.
I'll break it down: buying a fixer-upper isn't just about how good you are with a hammer. It's about whether you can afford what you're really signing up for, how long it will take, and how much stress you can handle. And here's a spoiler: most people seriously underestimate at least two of those three things.
Before we move on, let's make sure we know what the terms mean. When I'm working with our team on content strategy, I need to be exact. The same thing here.
A fixer-upper is a property that is worth less than what it is worth on the open market because it needs a lot of work before it can be lived in or sold for full price. We're not talking about houses that need a new coat of paint. We're talking about properties that have big problems that make them less safe, less appealing to buyers, or less livable.
The National Association of REALTORS®' 2024 Home Buyer and Seller Generational Trends Report says that about 13% of home purchases were for properties that buyers said needed a lot of work before they could be used. If a typical buyer walked through and saw the condition and then immediately started figuring out how much it would cost to fix it up instead of picturing where their furniture would go, you have a fixer-upper.
The range is very wide, though. At one end, there are cosmetic fixer-uppers that need new floors, updated fixtures, and maybe new kitchen cabinets. Depending on how big they are, these could cost $15,000 to $40,000 to fix up. On the other hand, you have structural problems that need foundation work, rewiring of the electrical system, replacement of the plumbing, or replacement of the roof. Those projects can easily cost more than $100,000.
This is the human side of it: How much your life gets messed up depends on how bad the fixer-upper is. A cosmetic update? You can usually stay in the house while the contractors work on the kitchen. You might even be able to camp out in the bedroom. A gut job? You either live somewhere else or in what is basically a construction site where you also sleep.
Let me show you the real numbers, because this is where most buyers go wrong. We learned in my MSW program about how financial stress affects families emotionally. Renovation budget surprises are always one of the top three things that stress people out about owning a home.
Real estate investors use something called the 70% rule as a quick assessment tool. Here's the calculation:
Maximum Purchase Price = (After Repair Value × 0.70) - Estimated Repair Costs
Let me show you how this works with a real example:
Example Property:
At the asking price of $180,000, you'd be paying $44,000 more than the 70% rule suggests. That doesn't mean it's automatically a bad deal, especially if you plan to live there long-term. But it does mean your profit margin has evaporated if you're thinking investment property.
The 70% calculation isn't arbitrary. That 30% buffer accounts for several hidden costs most buyers forget:
Add those up and you're looking at $36,800-$66,800 in costs beyond your purchase price and planned renovations.
According to HomeAdvisor's 2024 True Cost Report, here's what major renovation categories actually cost on average nationally:
Kitchen Remodel:
Bathroom Remodel:
Now here's where reality gets messy. These are average costs. Your costs depend on your geographic area, the quality of materials you choose, whether you're doing any work yourself, and crucially, what surprises are hiding behind those walls.
Let me be straight with you about the upsides, because they exist. They're just not always what you think they are.
The most obvious advantage is legitimate: fixer-uppers sell for less. According to data from Zillow Research's 2024 market analysis, homes listed as-is or described as needing TLC or handyman special sold for an average of 22% less than comparable move-in ready homes in the same neighborhoods.
Think of it like this: in a neighborhood where renovated homes sell for $300,000, you might find a fixer-upper for $230,000 to $240,000. That $60,000 to $70,000 difference is your opportunity. If you can renovate thoughtfully for $40,000 to $50,000, you've created $10,000 to $30,000 in equity immediately, plus you own a home in a neighborhood that might have otherwise been financially out of reach.
That equity matters. Not just as paper wealth, but as options. It's breathing room if something goes wrong financially. It's leverage for future borrowing if you need it. It's the difference between barely affording your mortgage and having a cushion.
The textbook answer is that fixer-uppers let you customize. But really, here's what that means in practice: you're not compromising on someone else's weird choices.
You know how you tour a house and the kitchen has that bizarre layout where the refrigerator is nowhere near the prep area? Or the primary bathroom has a massive jetted tub that you'd never use, eating up space where you'd rather have a larger shower? In a fixer-upper, those aren't problems you're stuck with. They're decisions you get to make based on how you actually live.
When we converted our garage into a home office a few years ago, we designed it specifically around how our family works. My husband needed space for his desk setup, I needed room for video calls and project planning, and we needed storage for all the kids' sports equipment that was otherwise colonizing our entire first floor. A move-in ready house wouldn't have given us that exact configuration.
This advantage has gotten more pronounced. According to the Mortgage Bankers Association's October 2025 Market Forecast, purchase mortgage applications for move-in ready homes remain highly competitive, with multiple offers common in desirable neighborhoods. But fixer-uppers? The competition pool shrinks dramatically.
Most buyers, especially first-time buyers, want something they can move into immediately. They're already stressed about the down payment, the mortgage, the moving process. Adding "and now you need to project manage a six-month renovation" pushes them into a different house.
That means if you have the financial bandwidth and stress tolerance for renovation, you're competing against a much smaller group of buyers. Often you can negotiate more effectively because sellers of fixer-uppers know their buyer pool is limited.
At AmeriSave, we work with buyers exploring fixer-upper purchases who recognize this advantage, especially when they're targeting neighborhoods where they'd otherwise be priced out of move-in ready options.
Here's something I've learned managing projects: when you control the process, you control the standards. With a fixer-upper, you're choosing the contractors, selecting the materials, and setting the quality expectations.
You want to see the work as it progresses? You can. You want to verify that the electrical work meets code before the walls close up? You can watch the inspection happen. You prefer engineered hardwood over laminate? Your choice. You want to invest in a high-efficiency HVAC system because you're planning to stay 10+ years and the energy savings matter? Go for it.
With a renovated home, you're trusting that whoever did the work made quality choices. Sometimes they did. Sometimes they did the bare minimum to make it look good for the showing. You're finding out which one five years later when problems emerge.
Okay, real talk for a second. The downsides of fixer-uppers are predictable in category but wildly variable in severity. That variability is what makes this decision so hard.
Always. Everyone I've talked to who works in construction, every project manager in our field, and every homeowner who's been through this says the same thing: plan for 20 to 30% more than you think you'll need.
The 2024 Renovation Survey from Houzz found that 78% of homeowners said their final costs were higher than what they had originally planned. The average overage was 27%. And listen, these people did plan ahead. These people got inspections, hired professionals, and made detailed budgets. The extra costs happened anyway.
Why? Because renovations reveal issues. You break into a bathroom wall to change the tub and find that the previous owner's brother, who was a handyman, did some creative plumbing that isn't up to code. You're not just changing the tub; you're also changing the plumbing in the bathroom. Your $12,000 bathroom makeover just cost you $18,000.
Or you find out that the framing is rotting when you replace the windows. Or you find out that the whole house needs new wiring while you're updating the electrical panel. Or you take down the kitchen and find that the floor joists are damaged by termites.
Here's the human side of this: surprises in the budget don't just cost money. They take a lot of emotional energy. You've been living in a construction zone for three months now. You're tired, you want it to be over, and now you find out it's going to take another month and cost $8,000 more. That stress affects everything in your life. You have less patience with your family. You don't sleep as well. Your ability to make decisions gets worse.
In my MSW class on how families deal with stress, financial uncertainty is always mentioned as one of the most destabilizing things. Surprises in the renovation budget hit that exact spot.
Let me paint you a picture. You close on your fixer-upper on March 1st. The contractor estimates 12 weeks for the major work. You're thinking you'll move in by June 1st. Here's what actually happens:
Week 1 to 2: Contractor starts demo and discovers issue number one with a plumbing problem. Needs to get new permits. Work stops while permitting happens.
Week 3: Work resumes. Dumpster arrives late. Material delivery delayed.
Week 4 to 6: Making good progress. Then the tile you ordered is backordered six weeks.
Week 7: Contractor's crew gets pulled to finish an emergency project for another client. Your project slows.
Week 8 to 10: Work continues, but now you're discovering that the electrical panel upgrade requires more work than estimated. Another permit delay.
Week 11 to 14: Kitchen coming together, but now the appliances you ordered won't be available until next month due to supply chain issues.
Week 15 to 18: Final details taking forever. Painting, fixture installation, punch list items keep appearing.
You move in August 15th. What was supposed to be 12 weeks turned into 24 weeks. If you were paying rent somewhere else during this time, you just paid an extra $9,000 to $12,000 in carrying costs you didn't budget for.
According to the National Association of Home Builders' 2024 Remodeling Report, the average substantial renovation project takes 47% longer than initially estimated. Almost half again as long.
You get a home inspection before you buy. Obviously. But here's the thing about inspecting fixer-uppers: inspectors can only inspect what they can see and access. They can't see inside walls, under flooring that's not removable, or into sealed areas.
According to the American Society of Home Inspectors' 2024 Industry Report, approximately 34% of major issues discovered during renovation were not identifiable during the pre-purchase inspection. Not because the inspector was incompetent, but because the issues weren't visible or accessible without invasive investigation.
You know what you discover when you start demo? Everything. The roof leak that's been slowly rotting the attic framing. The foundation crack that's hidden behind paneling in the basement. The knob-and-tube wiring that's buried in walls behind newer outlets that made it look like the electrical was updated.
These aren't theoretical problems. These are the calls I get from friends and family: "Casey, we started the renovation and found this problem, what do we do now?" The answer is almost always: fix it, add time, add money, adjust expectations.
It's hard to put a number on this, but it's real. It's hard to understand how tiring it is to live in a house that's being renovated until you do it.
It takes longer for everything. When you make dinner, you have to move around contractors' tools. Taking a shower means using the one bathroom that still works, even though three other people need it at the same time. Every weekday at 7 AM, there is noise from construction while you sleep. Privacy means... well, it's hard to have privacy when strangers are in your house 40 hours a week.
If you have kids, it's a lot harder. They trip over tools, breathe in construction dust, have to deal with noise while doing homework, and ask "when will it be done?" every day.
A 2023 study from the Journal of Environmental Psychology found that 68% of homeowners said that living in an active renovation caused them a lot of stress, which included trouble sleeping, more family conflict, and less happiness with life during the renovation.
The stress also has an effect on relationships. Renovation decisions need constant communication and agreement. The choice of tile, the style of the cabinets, whether to pay more for the higher-end faucet, and whether this surprise problem is bad enough to be worth the cost. Every choice could lead to a fight, and you're making dozens of choices every week while also being tired and stressed.
Let's talk about money with some actual specificity, because this is where fixer-upper dreams often collide with mathematics.
When you're building your renovation budget, you need several distinct categories:
Hard Costs with Materials and Labor: This is what most people think of as the budget. It's the contractor's estimate for lumber, drywall, tile, cabinets, appliances, and the labor to install everything.
For our hypothetical $60,000 renovation, that might break down like this:
Soft Costs, the Stuff You Forget:
Total soft costs: $7,100 to $18,200 with an average of $12,000
Carrying Costs:
Total carrying costs: $17,100 to $21,300 with an average of $19,000
Contingency Fund: Remember that 20 to 30% buffer? On $60,000 in hard costs, that's $12,000 to $18,000.
Total True Budget:
See how a "$60,000 renovation" actually requires $106,000 in total available funds? This is where people get into trouble. They have $60,000 saved, they start the project, and suddenly they're scrambling.
Let me walk you through the legitimate financing paths, because knowing these before you start shopping changes what's possible.
FHA 203(k) Rehabilitation Loan:
This program, updated by the Department of Housing and Urban Development in their 2024 Standard 203(k) program revisions, lets you roll renovation costs into your mortgage. Here's how it works:
You're buying that $180,000 fixer-upper. You estimate $60,000 in renovations. With FHA 203(k), you can get a single loan for $240,000 (plus closing costs). The additional $60,000 goes into an escrow account that releases funds as renovation milestones complete.
Requirements:
Fannie Mae HomeStyle Renovation Mortgage:
Similar concept, different requirements. You can finance up to 97% of the after-repair value, not the purchase price.
You'd only need to bring 3% of the after-repair value as down payment, which is $8,400, and you'd have $91,600 available for renovations.
Requirements:
At AmeriSave, we help buyers evaluate whether specialized renovation financing makes sense for their situation, though it's worth noting these products require significantly more documentation and planning than standard purchase loans.
Conventional Financing Plus Separate Renovation Loan:
You can use regular financing to buy the specialized products if they don't work for you, and then get a separate personal loan, home equity loan, or line of credit to pay for the renovations.
This method gives you more freedom with contractors and the timeline, but you have to pay more interest on the renovation part and qualify for both loans.
This is critical, and it's where a lot of fixer-upper buyers make expensive mistakes. The textbook answer is that renovations increase home value. But the reality is more complicated.
According to Remodeling Magazine's 2024 Cost vs. Value Report, here's what common renovations actually return when you sell:
Notice something? Most renovations don't return their full cost. That $30,000 kitchen remodel adds about $16,200 to your home's value. That's not a good investment if your goal is profit.
But location matters enormously. The same kitchen remodel might return 90% in a strong appreciation market and only 40% in a declining area. CoreLogic's 2024 Market Analysis says that location is responsible for about 60–70% of the difference in resale value, while condition and renovations are only responsible for 30–40%.
In other words, fixing up a house in a neighborhood that is getting worse is almost always a bad idea financially. You're putting money into something that's losing value because of things you can't change.
If you want to make money, buy the worst house in a good, growing neighborhood and fix it up to meet the standards of the neighborhood. Not going over them, but matching them. You won't get your money back if you over-improve your neighborhood.
Okay, so here's what happened when my brother-in-law bought his fixer-upper in 2023. He hired a home inspector, got the standard inspection report, felt good about the disclosed issues, and proceeded. Four weeks into renovation, they discovered extensive termite damage in the floor joists that wasn't visible during inspection. $22,000 in unexpected structural repairs.
Could this have been prevented? Maybe. Here's what a more thorough pre-purchase investigation looks like:
Layer 1: Standard Home Inspection Cost: $400-$600 What it covers: All visible, accessible systems and components
This is your baseline. Every fixer-upper needs this, minimum. But it's not sufficient.
Layer 2: Specialized Inspections Based on age and condition, consider:
Total additional inspections: $1,325 to $3,500 depending on what's needed
Layer 3: Contractor Walk-Through Before you make your offer, and yes I mean before, bring a general contractor through the property. Not for a bid yet but just for a reality check. Experienced contractors spot problems inspectors miss because they're seeing it through a how would I fix this lens.
Cost: Often free if contractor expects you might hire them, otherwise $100 to $300 for their time.
This step has saved buyers I know tens of thousands of dollars. The contractor sees that the "simple kitchen remodel" actually requires moving gas lines, which means permits and inspections. Or that the foundation issues are more extensive than they appear. Or that the roof, while not leaking currently, has maybe two years of life left.
Once you're serious about a property, you need actual bids. Not guesses, not ranges from articles (like this one), but real estimates from contractors who've walked the property.
Here's the process:
List every single thing you want done. Be specific:
The more specific you are, the more accurate the bid will be.
At least three, but five would be better. Not to always pick the cheapest, but to know the range and find the outliers.
If you get bids of $58,000, $62,000, $61,000, $65,000, and $110,000, the one that is much higher than the others is an outlier. It could be that the contractor doesn't want the job. It's possible that they see problems that the others don't. You should look into it before moving forward.
You need to know what your $60,000 bid actually includes and what will cost extra.
If the contractor says 12 weeks, plan for 16 to 18 weeks. According to NAHB contractor surveys, 82% of renovation projects exceed initial timeline estimates. Your contractor isn't lying to you. They're giving you their best estimate. But delays happen: material delays, weather if any exterior work, permit delays, discovery of additional problems, subcontractor scheduling.
Working with a real estate agent who knows a lot about investment properties or renovations in your target area is the easiest way to go. The National Association of REALTORS®' 2024 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers says that buyers who used specialized agents for fixer-uppers were 32% happier with the buying process and the results.
Why agents who are experts in their field are important: They know contractors, inspectors, and lenders who know how to finance renovations. They know how to spot problems because they've finished many renovation projects. They know which problems they can handle and which ones are disasters.
Not all fixer-uppers are worth fixing. According to contractor surveys compiled by HomeAdvisor's 2024 analysis, these issues most commonly resulted in projects being abandoned:
The math is simple: if the worst case cost exceeds your maximum budget by 50% or more, walk away. If the property needs $100,000 in work and your maximum budget is $60,000, it doesn't matter how good the price is.
Let me walk you through what the actual calendar looks like, because understanding the timeline helps you plan everything else:
Total timeline: 9 months from starting your search to moving in.
This is based on the idea that everything will go pretty well. If you add in things like delays in getting permits, problems with scheduling contractors, problems with getting materials, or finding major problems, you could be looking at 11 to 14 months.
If you're renting while this is going on, you're paying $1,500 to $2,500 a month for 9 months, which adds up to $13,500 to $22,500 in rent you wouldn't have to pay if you bought a move-in ready home. You need to take that into account when figuring out if you saved money.
Here's the decision most fixer-upper buyers agonize over: where do we live during this?
Pros:
Cons:
Best for: Major renovations where kitchen and bathrooms are gutted, making daily living impractical.
Pros:
Cons:
Best for: Cosmetic renovations or phased renovations where one part of house remains livable.
Renovate in stages, moving around the house as different areas complete. For example:
Pros:
Cons:
According to renovation surveys, approximately 58% of homeowners doing substantial renovations choose to live elsewhere during the major work phases, despite the additional cost.
This section might sound boring, but skipping permits creates massive problems. In Louisville, where I live, permit enforcement has gotten significantly stricter in the past few years. Inspectors are checking, and unpermitted work creates problems when you try to sell.
Renovations That Almost Always Require Permits:
According to the International Code Council's 2024 building code updates adopted by most municipalities:
Renovations That Often Don't Require Permits:
The specific requirements vary by municipality. Your contractor should know local requirements, but you're ultimately responsible. If they do unpermitted work, you face the consequences when you sell.
Permit Process Basics:
Permit costs and timeline delays must be factored into your budget and schedule.
The textbook answer is "DIY saves money." But the real answer is more complicated, because your time has value and your skill level matters enormously.
Projects Where DIY Typically Makes Sense:
Potential savings: 40-60% of contractor costs for these items
Projects Where DIY Is Risky:
Potential savings: 30-50% of contractor costs, but risks often exceed savings
DIY Painting Example:
If you make substantially more than $42.50 per hour at your job and could work extra during those hours, DIY may not actually save money. But if you'd be using personal time anyway, or if you enjoy the work, the savings are real.
DIY Electrical Example:
Some work should always be contracted out. The risks exceed any potential savings.
Once you've found a property you want, making a smart offer requires balancing several factors.
Offer Price Calculation:
But that's your maximum. Your opening offer should typically be 10 to 15% below that, expecting negotiation. So maybe $115,000 to $125,000.
According to NAR's 2024 buyer survey data, successful fixer-upper negotiations typically involved 2 to 4 rounds of offer and counteroffer before reaching agreement, with final sale prices averaging 8 to 12% below initial asking price.
You've done your inspections, you've gotten contractor bids, and now you're realizing this property is going to cost significantly more than you thought. When do you walk away?
The best fixer-upper deal is the one you don't do because the numbers didn't work.
At AmeriSave, we help buyers run these calculations before they get emotionally invested, providing clarity on what's financially feasible within their budget and risk tolerance.
The only types of mortgages that don't require a down payment are VA loans for veterans who qualify and USDA loans for homes in certain rural areas. Both programs require that the home be your main residence and that it meet certain minimum standards for property condition. Veterans Affairs lending data from 2024 says that VA loans can be used for homes that need repairs, but the home must be livable when the loan closes. The property must be in better shape for USDA loans. If you want to buy a fixer-upper without putting any money down, you might only be able to make cosmetic changes instead of big ones to the systems or structure. Most people who buy a fixer-upper need to put down at least 3% to 5% of the purchase price and get money to pay for the repairs. If they want to use traditional financing, they need to put down 20% and get separate money for the repairs. To buy a fixer-upper with no money down, you need to use a special renovation loan like the FHA 203k. This loan still requires a down payment of at least 3.5% of the total project cost.
It all depends on the state of your local market, how well you stick to your renovation budget, and how long you have to finish the work. CoreLogic's market analysis from October 2025 says that home values in most major metro areas have gone up 4 to 6% each year for the past three years. This means that buying fixer-uppers in neighborhoods that are going up in value could be a good investment. However, NAHB data shows that contractor costs have gone up 18% since 2022, and labor shortages have made projects take longer, which has cut into profits. If you're buying in a neighborhood that is going up in value, can accurately estimate renovation costs within 15% of what they will actually be, have enough money set aside to deal with surprises, and plan to keep the property for at least three to five years, a fixer-upper can be a great investment. If you're buying in a neighborhood that's going down, don't plan to flip it quickly (in less than 18 months), or don't have extra money set aside for budget overruns, it's usually not a good investment. Instead of asking yourself if this is a good investment, ask yourself if your numbers work in your market.
Use the full formula: For a comfortable profit margin, the purchase price, total renovation costs, soft costs, carrying costs, and contingency must all be less than 75% of the after-repair value. This is an example of how to do it: You see a house for sale for $180,000 that would sell for $280,000 after it has been fixed up. Your contractor says that the work will cost $60,000. Add $12,000 in soft costs like permits and fees. Add $19,000 in carrying costs over six months for the renovation. Put aside $15,000 for unexpected costs, which is 20% of the total. The total amount you would invest would be $286,000, which is $180,000 plus $60,000 plus $12,000 plus $19,000 plus $15,000. That is more than your after-repair value of $280,000, which means you would lose money. You can only buy this property if you can get the price down to between $130,000 and $140,000, or if your estimate of the home's value after repairs is low and it would actually sell for between $310,000 and $320,000. You can quickly find your maximum purchase price by using the 70% rule: multiply the after-repair value by 0.70 and then subtract the total cost of the renovation. In this case, $280,000 times 0.70 equals $196,000. Then, $60,000 in hard costs is taken away, leaving a maximum purchase price of $136,000.
The Remodeling Magazine's 2024 Cost vs. Value Report says that the renovations that give the best return on investment are: minor kitchen remodels (85% cost recovery), bathroom additions (63% cost recovery), roof replacement (107% cost recovery because buyers want it), and HVAC system replacement (95% cost recovery). But the real value added depends a lot on what is normal in the neighborhood. If all the other homes in your neighborhood have updated kitchens, remodeling your kitchen will bring your home up to market standards, not above them. You're not making something better; you're getting rid of something bad. Put most of your renovation money toward fixing things that could ruin the deal, like broken systems like the roof, HVAC, plumbing, and electrical, and bringing the kitchen and bathrooms up to neighborhood standards. Anything more than that usually costs less than 60% of what it costs. The biggest mistake that people who buy fixer-uppers make is putting in too many luxury features that don't add value because homes in the area don't support that value. You should aim to meet the neighborhood standard, not go above it.
According to the National Association of Home Builders, major renovations that involve more than one room and system take an average of 6 to 9 months from getting a permit to finishing the work. About 47% of projects take longer than expected. If there are no structural problems, cosmetic changes like painting, flooring, and updating fixtures could be done in 6 to 8 weeks. Once the materials are ordered and delivered, kitchen renovations usually take 8 to 12 weeks. It usually takes 4 to 6 weeks to completely remodel a bathroom. Renovating a whole house with changes to multiple systems, the structure, and the design usually takes 9 to 14 months. According to surveys of contractors, the most common reason for delays is finding hidden problems during demolition. This happens in about 73% of renovation projects. Since 2022, delays in getting materials have become more common. For example, custom cabinets, windows, and some tile choices can take 8 to 16 weeks to get from order to delivery. Add 40 to 50% more time to the contractor's estimate when making your timeline so that you have realistic expectations. Plan for 14 to 15 weeks if a contractor says 10 weeks. If they say six months, plan on eight to nine months. This keeps you from worrying about money because of delays you didn't see coming and helps you plan your living arrangements more accurately.
Fixer-uppers need more than just a regular home inspection; they need a special look at any major problems that could cost a lot of money. The American Society of Home Inspectors says that you should first check the structural integrity of the house, including the foundation, floor, and roof framing, as well as the age and capacity of the electrical system, looking for old 60-amp panels or knob-and-tube wiring; the plumbing system's materials and condition, since replacing galvanized pipes can cost between $8,000 and $15,000; the HVAC system's age and functionality, since replacing it can cost between $6,000 and $12,000; and any signs of water intrusion, such as mold, rot, or staining, which could mean that there have been or are leaks. Get a pest inspection that looks for termites, carpenter ants, and wood-boring beetles. Damage from these pests can cost $10,000 to $30,000 to fix. If the property has a septic system, you should have it pumped and inspected completely. Replacing a septic system can cost between $15,000 and $50,000. Check the quality of the water in the well and make sure the well is deep enough and the pump is working. If you see cracks in the foundation, sagging floors, or gaps between walls and ceilings, you should have a structural engineer look at them. These could be signs of costly structural problems. The goal is to find any problems that could cost more than $10,000 to fix before you buy.
For a standard conventional or FHA mortgage, the property must meet minimum property standards, which means it must be safe, sound, and clean. If a house has missing handrails, exposed wiring, broken heating, structural damage, or other safety problems, it won't be able to get traditional financing. This is when specialized renovation mortgages are very important. FHA 203k loans let you buy a home and make repairs with one loan. The property doesn't have to meet standards at the time of purchase because the repairs are included in the loan. Fannie Mae HomeStyle renovation loans do the same thing for traditional loans. Before a loan can be approved, these programs need detailed contractor bids, architectural plans, and sometimes even engineer reports. The lender keeps the money for renovations in an escrow account and gives it to the borrower as work is done and inspections are passed. Freddie Mac's lending data from 2024 shows that about 3% of purchase mortgages included renovation financing programs. If the property is in such bad shape that it can't even get renovation financing, you'll need to buy it with cash or get a hard money loan with high interest rates for a short time. Before you spend time and money on inspections, AmeriSave can help you figure out if your target property and renovation plans are compatible with the financing options that are available.
This nightmare situation happens more often than buyers think it will. According to data from a Houzz renovation survey, about 22% of homeowners said they ran out of money for their renovation before it was done and had to get more money. You can stop work at a logical pause point and save more money if you've done enough to make the space usable but are still living in partial construction. You can also take out a personal loan to finish the work at 8 to 12% interest rates, but you need to have qualifying income and credit. If you have enough equity, you can set up a home equity line of credit, but the property must be at least minimally habitable. You can also borrow from retirement accounts like 401k plans, but this is usually not recommended because of tax implications and lost growth. Finally, you can bring in family funding with clear repayment terms. It's clear that prevention is better: before you start, set aside an extra 25 to 30% of what your contractor says it will cost. If you have $60,000 to spend on renovations, you should have $75,000 to $78,000 ready. Some buyers cut back on the scope of their renovations halfway through the project, only finishing the most important systems and structural work and putting off cosmetic updates. You could finish the kitchen renovation but put off the bathroom upgrade, finish the flooring but put off the deck addition, or put in builder-grade fixtures now and upgrade them later. The worst thing that can happen is to stop in the middle of a project with major systems exposed or unfinished. This is dangerous and can cause more damage from being outside in the weather.
There isn't one right answer; it depends on your priorities, skills, and money situation. If you have a renovation budget plus 25 to 30% more than your down payment and closing costs, can handle 6 to 12 months of construction disruption or pay for alternate housing, have time to oversee contractor work or enough trust to monitor remotely, can handle timeline uncertainty and budget surprises without too much stress, and want to build equity through forced appreciation in a neighborhood you couldn't otherwise afford, then you should buy a fixer-upper. Buy move-in ready if you need to move in right away for work or family reasons, don't have the money to deal with unexpected renovation costs, can't handle the disruption of construction with your current life situation (like having young children, health problems, or a busy work schedule), prefer predictable monthly costs to changing renovation costs, or value your time much more than the money you could save. According to NAR buyer data, 83% of first-time buyers choose homes that are ready to move into, while 28% of repeat buyers with more equity and experience choose homes that need work. You can only save money on fixer-uppers if you accurately estimate costs, manage the project well, and don't go over budget by more than 20% to 25%. If you're not sure what to do, "move-in ready" is probably the safer choice. Buyers who go into a fixer-upper with their eyes wide open about the problems are the best ones. Buyers who romanticize the process are not.
Before you make your offer, do the full value analysis. To figure out the after-repair value, look up recently sold homes in the same neighborhood that are in great shape and are similar in size. Databases of property values, like Zillow, show recent sale prices. However, for accuracy, use actual closed sales from your real estate agent's MLS access. Then add up all the costs: the purchase price, the hard renovation costs (materials and labor), the soft costs (permits, inspections, and fees), the carrying costs (mortgage, tax, insurance, and utilities during the renovation), and 25% for unexpected expenses. If your total costs are more than 75% of the value of the property after repairs, you are likely to lose money or just break even. For quick filtering, use the 70% rule: take the after-repair value and multiply it by 0.70, then take away the estimated hard renovation costs. The result is the most you can pay for a profitable outcome. If the sellers won't agree to that number or lower, and you're buying it as an investment instead of a long-term home, walk away. You can be less strict when buying a primary residence if you plan to live there for 7 to 10 years because you're getting more out of the home than just making money. But you shouldn't pay so much that you would lose money if you had to sell in three to five years. CoreLogic market data shows that you need at least 20% equity cushion to ride out short-term market changes without losing money.
Fact Checked
