Trustpilot
Loading...
Loading...Loading...
Okay, so mortgage rates hung around 6-7% for most of 2024 and into 2025, and a lot of potential buyers found themselves stuck. According to Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey, the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage averaged 6.22% in late 2025. While that's better than the highs we saw earlier, it's still triple what we had during the pandemic years, and for some buyers especially those with non-traditional income or credit challenges even qualifying at these rates feels impossible.
That's where private mortgages come in. They're not new, but they're definitely getting more attention as traditional lending tightens up. Think of it like this: when the front door is locked, sometimes you need to find a side entrance. Private mortgages are that alternative path, and while they come with their own set of challenges, understanding them can open possibilities you didn't know existed.
A private mortgage is basically a home loan from an individual person or private company instead of a bank or credit union. These lenders use their own funds or investor capital, set their own rules, and don't have to follow the same strict guidelines that traditional lenders do. According to ICE Mortgage Monitor's May 2025 report, first-time home buyers accounted for a record 58% of agency purchase lending in Q1 2025, highlighting how challenging the traditional market has become for many buyers.
Here's the human side of this. In my Master’s of Social Work (MSW) program, we learned about how financial stress affects families emotionally, and I see that playing out in the mortgage market every day. People feel stuck between wanting to own a home and facing barriers they can't control - credit scores that don't tell their whole story, self-employment income that looks irregular on paper, or savings that went to medical bills instead of a bigger down payment.
Private mortgages work differently than what you might expect from traditional lenders. Instead of focusing primarily on your credit score and debt-to-income ratio, private lenders look at the property itself as collateral. They're asking, "If this borrower can't pay, can I recoup my investment through this property?" That asset-based approach means they can be more flexible about who they lend to, but it also means they're taking on more risk, which they offset with higher interest rates and fees.
According to BeSmartee's Q1 2025 Mortgage Lending Report, non-qualified mortgage (Non-QM) loans saw increased demand in Q1 2025 as affordability challenges pushed more borrowers toward alternative financing. This isn't surprising when you consider that total mortgage origination dropped by approximately 6.7% in Q1 2025 compared to the previous year, marking some of the lowest volumes since 2000.
Private mortgage lenders fall into a few categories. You've got high-net-worth individuals who see lending as an investment opportunity, offering better returns than traditional investments. There are small private companies specializing in hard money loans, particularly for real estate investors. Sometimes it's family members willing to finance a home purchase directly. And increasingly, you'll find organized private lending firms that operate more like traditional lenders but without the same regulatory constraints.
What this means for you is that the experience can vary dramatically depending on who you're working with. A family member might offer incredibly generous terms but create complicated personal dynamics. A hard money lender will be all business, focused on the numbers and their exit strategy. An individual investor might fall somewhere in between.
At AmeriSave, we focus on helping borrowers explore all their options, and sometimes that means being honest when a private mortgage might make sense or when it absolutely doesn't.
Let's talk about where we are right now. According to the Federal Reserve Bank of New York's Q3 2025 Household Debt and Credit Report, Americans collectively owe $13.07 trillion in mortgage debt as of September 2025, representing approximately 70% of the total $18.59 trillion in household debt. That's a staggering amount of mortgage debt, and it reflects both how many people own homes and how expensive homes have become.
But here's what they never tell you in the statistics the market is tough for new buyers right now. According to Acuity Knowledge Partners' 2025 U.S. Mortgage Trends report, the housing shortage persists mainly due to under-building during the past 10 years, and while construction is starting to recover, the rate lock-in factor has inversely affected growth. Translation: people with low-rate mortgages from 2020-2021 aren't selling because they don't want to give up their 3% rates for 6-7% rates.
This creates opportunity for private lenders. When traditional financing feels out of reach and inventory is tight, buyers sometimes need creative solutions. But and this is important creative doesn't always mean good for you.
What this means for you is real money out of your pocket. While traditional mortgages averaged around 6.72% in 2024, private mortgage interest rates typically range from 8% to 15% or even higher. On a $300,000 loan, that difference between 6.5% and 12% translates to roughly $1,100 more per month that's $13,200 per year in additional interest.
Think of it like this: you're paying a premium for flexibility and speed. Whether that premium is worth it depends entirely on your situation and alternatives.
Remember I mentioned this isn't your typical 30-year mortgage? Most private mortgages run 6 to 36 months. That's one to three years, not three decades. According to industry data, these short-term loans are structured assuming you'll either refinance into traditional financing once your credit improves, sell the property, or have another exit strategy.
Short terms reduce lender risk, but really, what you need to understand is this creates pressure. You've got to have a solid plan for what happens when that loan comes due. I've seen people assume they'll just refinance when the time comes, only to discover their credit situation hasn't improved enough or property values have shifted unexpectedly.
Here's something that might surprise you. While traditional lenders are pretty strict about down payment requirements, private lenders often negotiate. Some might accept 10-15% down, others might want 25-30% or more depending on the property and your situation. According to ICE's Q1 2025 Mortgage Monitor, first-time home buyers using VA mortgages had average down payments of just under $10,000, showing the range of what's possible with different loan types.
With private lenders, everything's negotiable. That can work in your favor if you have strong points to negotiate with, like excellent property value, solid income you can demonstrate, or relationships with the lender.
This is one area where private mortgages genuinely shine. Traditional mortgages can take 30-45 days or longer. Private mortgages? Sometimes days, occasionally weeks at most. When you're in a competitive market or facing a time-sensitive situation, that speed matters.
But here's what nobody mentions in class fast isn't always better. Speed means less scrutiny, which sounds great until you realize that scrutiny exists partly to protect you from terms you shouldn't accept. Don't let urgency push you into a bad deal.
Let me be real with you for a second. Traditional mortgages come with a ton of consumer protections built in things like the Truth in Lending Act, Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act, and ability-to-repay rules. According to the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, federal laws like the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act and Equal Credit Opportunity Act provide critical safeguards for borrowers.
Private mortgages? Not necessarily. The regulatory framework is much lighter, which is actually why private lenders can move faster and be more flexible. But it also means if something goes wrong, your recourse is more limited. If a private lender suddenly changes terms or engages in predatory practices, you might find yourself in legal territory that's complicated and expensive to navigate.
Okay, so here's what happened with balloon payments and why they concern me. A balloon payment structure means you make regular payments sometimes interest-only for the loan term, then the entire remaining balance comes due at the end. So you might pay $1,500 monthly for two years, then owe $285,000 all at once.
The theory is you'll refinance or sell before that balloon comes due. The reality? Life doesn't always cooperate. Markets shift, refinancing falls through, or your financial situation changes. According to Milliman's Q1 2025 Mortgage Market Report, mortgage lenders lost $28 for every loan originated in Q1 2025, indicating how tight lending conditions have become. That kind of market makes refinancing more challenging.
While private lenders typically don't charge private mortgage insurance (PMI), they often charge higher origination fees and points. Traditional lenders might charge 0.5-1% in origination fees. Private lenders? Sometimes 2-5% or more. On a $300,000 loan, that could be $15,000 in upfront fees versus $3,000.
You need to calculate the total cost of the loan, not just the monthly payment. What this means for you is looking at the annual percentage rate (APR), which includes fees, not just the interest rate.
Here's the human side of this decision. People get excited about getting approved and finally being able to buy. That's natural. But with a private mortgage, how you're going to get out of it matters more than how you got into it.
Will you genuinely be able to improve your credit enough to refinance? Is your income going to stabilize or increase? Are you counting on property appreciation that might not happen? These aren't rhetorical questions you need honest answers before signing.
Let me simplify this for you by breaking down the situations where private mortgages actually make sense versus where they're just expensive desperation moves.
If you've been self-employed for less than two years or have complex income structures, traditional lenders can be incredibly frustrating. They want two years of tax returns showing stable income, but maybe you just launched a successful business or your income varies seasonally. Private lenders can look at your actual business revenue, bank statements, and profit trends rather than just tax returns.
According to National Mortgage News' 2025 industry challenges report, lenders are looking for ways to open up credit to more borrowers as insurance costs and affordability challenges create barriers. For self-employed borrowers, private financing sometimes bridges that gap.
Maybe you had medical bills that tanked your credit, went through a divorce, or had a bankruptcy a few years back. Your credit score says 580, but you're now earning $85,000 annually with stable employment. Traditional lenders see that 580 and often stop there. Private lenders might see the whole picture and be willing to work with you.
But here's the catch you need to have actually addressed whatever caused the credit issues. If you're still struggling with debt management, a high-interest private mortgage will make things worse, not better.
Real estate investors use private mortgages all the time because they're buying properties to renovate and sell quickly. They need fast closes and don't care about high short-term interest rates because they're holding the property for six months, not six years. For investors, private mortgages often make perfect sense.
For primary residence buyers? The math is completely different. You're not flipping you're living there. Those high rates compound over time.
If you're buying from a family member, a private mortgage between family can actually work beautifully. Your parents might offer you a rate better than banks while still getting a return better than savings accounts. You avoid some closing costs and can structure terms that work for everyone.
Just be careful. Money and family can get complicated fast. Having everything formally documented with an attorney isn't pessimistic it's protective for everyone involved.
At AmeriSave, we've seen all kinds of creative solutions, and sometimes helping clients means pointing them toward resources that make sense for their unique situation, even when that's not a traditional loan product.
In my MSW program, we learned about how to recognize when someone's in a vulnerable position being exploited, and that definitely applies here.
If you're seeing any of these red flags, step back and get independent advice before proceeding:
According to PerformLine's 2025 mortgage compliance report, regulatory changes remain a significant challenge, with 54% of roundtable participants identifying it as the biggest anticipated challenge in 2025. This regulatory environment means legitimate lenders are being more careful, so anyone offering suspiciously easy terms might not have your best interests at heart.
Before you commit to a private mortgage, here's what this means for you explore these options first. Most of them offer better long-term value and more protections:
FHA loans are designed specifically for borrowers with credit challenges. You can qualify with scores as low as 580 with 3.5% down, or even 500 with 10% down in some cases. The mortgage insurance is higher than conventional loans, but the overall cost is typically much lower than private mortgages.
If you've served in the military, VA loans often require zero down payment and have competitive rates. According to the Department of Veterans Affairs, VA loans don't require private mortgage insurance, which can save thousands annually.
Many state and local programs offer grants or low-interest loans to help with down payments. These can be combined with conventional or government-backed loans to reduce your upfront costs and improve your loan terms.
Sometimes the best solution is waiting six months to a year while actively improving your credit. Yeah, I know, nobody wants to hear "wait." But think of it like this: if waiting one year gets you a 6.5% rate instead of a 12% rate, you're saving thousands every single year you own that home. The math clearly favors patience when possible.
Non-QM (non-qualified mortgage) loans are a middle ground. They're more flexible than traditional mortgages but more regulated than pure private mortgages. According to BeSmartee's Q1 2025 report, these loans saw increased demand in Q1 2025, and they're worth exploring before going the private route.
If after considering everything, a private mortgage still seems like your best option, here's how to protect yourself through the process:
Before anything else, talk to a real estate attorney. Not the lender's attorney your own. They can review loan documents, explain what you're signing, and catch problematic terms. Yes, this costs money upfront. It's still cheaper than signing a bad loan.
Check if the lender is licensed in your state. Look for reviews, complaints, or legal actions. Search their name with terms like "complaints" or "scam" and see what comes up. If they're legitimate, this information should be available and clean.
No handshake deals. No "we'll figure it out later." Every term, every condition, every fee needs to be clearly documented in writing before you sign anything. If they won't put it in writing, that tells you something important.
Calculate what you'll actually pay over the life of the loan. If it's a two-year loan at 10% interest on $300,000, what's your total payment? What are the fees? What's your exit strategy cost? Do the complete math, not just the monthly payment math.
"I'll just refinance in two years" isn't a strategy it's a hope. What specifically will you do to improve your creditworthiness? What if rates go up instead of down? What if the appraisal comes in lower than expected? Have backup plans.
Pay for your own property appraisal from a licensed appraiser. Don't rely solely on the lender's valuation. You need an objective assessment of what you're actually buying.
Here's the textbook answer: private mortgages can be appropriate short-term solutions for specific situations where traditional financing isn't available and you have a clear path to refinancing or repayment. But really, what you need to understand is this: private mortgages are expensive tools that should only be used when they genuinely open doors that would otherwise remain closed.
If you can't answer yes to all of those questions, a private mortgage probably isn't your best option right now.
One thing I've learned from managing projects in the mortgage industry is that the best decisions come from having the right information and the right people in your corner. Whether you're exploring private mortgages or traditional financing, working with experienced professionals makes all the difference.
AmeriSave specializes in helping borrowers navigate complex financing situations and find solutions that actually work for their long-term financial health. If you're not sure whether a private mortgage makes sense or if you have other options available, our loan experts can walk you through the possibilities specific to your situation.
Let me simplify this entire discussion: private mortgages are powerful financial tools that come with significant risks and costs. They offer flexibility and speed that traditional lenders can't match, but you pay a premium for those advantages through higher rates, shorter terms, and fewer protections.
In 2025's challenging housing market, with rates still elevated and affordability concerns persistent, more buyers are considering alternative financing. According to Expert Market Research's Mortgage Lending Market report, the market is projected to grow at 9.80% CAGR between 2025 and 2034, driven partly by increased adoption of flexible financing options.
I want you to get into a home you love, but I want that home to be a source of stability and pride instead of financial stress. That can mean coming up with creative ways to solve problems, like private mortgages. It can mean waiting, building credit, and doing things differently at times. You are the only one who can choose the right path, but make sure you have all the facts and expert advice before you do.
An AmeriSave loan expert can help you look at all your options and find the best mortgage for your needs if you're not sure where to start. The best way to move forward may be one you haven't thought of yet.
Individuals or private businesses, not banks, credit unions, or licensed mortgage companies, give out private mortgages. The main differences are in the rules, the standards for getting approval, and the cost. Private lenders don't have to follow the same federal rules that traditional lenders do. They can set their own terms. They usually look at the value of the property instead of the borrower's credit score. This means they are more likely to approve loans, but the interest rates are higher and the terms are shorter. Traditional lenders have to follow strict rules, like rules about how much money a borrower can afford to pay back and laws that protect consumers. There are fewer rules for private lenders, which gives borrowers more freedom but also more risk. The process of getting approved by private lenders can take days instead of weeks or months. However, you pay for that speed with higher costs and less legal protection if something goes wrong.
Yes, it is possible to refinance from a private mortgage to a traditional mortgage. In fact, this is often part of the plan when you take out a private mortgage. Most private mortgages are set up as short-term solutions that last one to three years. The idea is that borrowers will refinance into regular loans once their credit scores go up, their income documentation becomes more stable, or they build up more equity in the property. Refinancing, on the other hand, isn't guaranteed and depends on a number of things, such as how much your credit has improved, how stable your job history is, how much your property is worth, and the state of the lending market at the time. You usually need a credit score of at least 620 for a conventional loan or 580 for an FHA loan, proof of income that meets debt-to-income requirements, and enough equity or a better financial situation. The most important thing is to have a realistic plan for how you'll meet the requirements for traditional loans instead of just hoping that refinancing will work out when the time comes.
When it comes to costs, private mortgages are much more expensive than regular loans. Freddie Mac data shows that conventional mortgage rates were around 6.22% in late 2025, while interest rates on private mortgages usually range from 8% to 15% per year. If you take out a $300,000 loan, the difference between a 6.5% conventional rate and a 12% private rate is about $1,100 more per month or more than $13,000 per year in extra interest costs. In addition to interest rates, private lenders often charge origination fees of 2% to 5% or more of the loan amount, while traditional lenders only charge 0.5% to 1%. So, for a $300,000 loan, you'll have to pay $6,000 to $15,000 in fees up front, while for traditional financing, you'll only have to pay $1,500 to $3,000. Some private lenders charge a fee if you pay off the loan early, which is not something that most traditional mortgages do. Many private loans don't require private mortgage insurance, but the overall cost difference is so big that you should only think about private mortgages when traditional financing isn't really an option.
When set up correctly with the right legal paperwork and clear communication, getting a private mortgage from a family member can be safe and good for both parties. A lot of families use this arrangement because it works out well for both sides. The buyer gets better terms and lower interest rates than they would from a commercial private lender, and the family lender gets better returns than they would from a regular savings or investment account. A family member or parent who lends money can also help a family member buy a home who might not otherwise be able to. But for the deal to work, it needs to be treated with the same seriousness as a business loan. You need to have a real estate lawyer write up loan documents that spell out the loan amount, interest rate, payment schedule, what happens if payments are missed, and how the property secures the loan. To protect both parties legally, the loan should be properly recorded with the county. You should also think about the tax effects because the IRS says that family loans must charge at least the federal interest rate. If the terms are too good, there may also be gift tax issues. The biggest risk isn't money, but relationships. Money problems can hurt family relationships if everyone doesn't agree on what they expect from the start.
One reason private mortgages are appealing to people with credit problems is that they don't have the same strict credit score requirements as traditional mortgages. Most conventional mortgages need credit scores of at least 620, and FHA loans need scores of at least 580. However, private lenders often work with borrowers who have scores in the 500s or even lower. This is because private lenders don't rely on credit history as much as they do on the value of the property and their ability to get their money back through foreclosure if they need to. Your credit score still matters, though, because it will affect the terms you are offered. If you have a 550 credit score and want the same private mortgage as someone with a 620 score, you will probably have to pay more in interest, make a bigger down payment, and follow stricter loan terms. Some private lenders don't even look at credit scores. They only look at the value of the property, the amount of your down payment, and the proof of your income. Even though there is no credit score requirement, you should still be ready to show that you can make payments by providing bank statements, proof of income, and an explanation of any past credit problems.
If you can't pay back your private mortgage when it's due, the results can be bad because private mortgages usually don't have as many protections for consumers as traditional mortgages do. Most private mortgages are short-term loans with either a balloon payment due at the end or regular payments that leave a balloon balance at the end. If you can't refinance, sell the property, or pay off the loan when it ends, the private lender can start the foreclosure process on the property, just like any other mortgage lender. Private lenders don't have to work with you like some traditional lenders do. They can go straight to foreclosure to get their money back. Some private mortgage contracts also have penalty clauses, default fees, or acceleration clauses that can make things worse if you miss a payment or don't follow the repayment terms. This is why it's so important to have a realistic plan for how to get out of a private mortgage before you take one out. You need to know exactly how you'll either refinance into a traditional loan or pay off the loan when it's due. You should also have backup plans in case your main plan doesn't work out. Most private mortgages have short loan terms that put a lot of pressure on you and set strict deadlines that you need to plan for carefully before you sign.
Yes, some types of properties are more likely to be financed with private mortgages than others. This is mostly because private lenders look at the property's value and how easy it is to sell to determine how risky it is. Private mortgages are great for investment properties like rental homes and fix-and-flip projects because investors often need quick closes and short-term financing that fits with their project schedules. Private financing works well for properties that aren't owner-occupied because the lender doesn't have to worry about following primary residence lending rules. Another good fit is homes that need a lot of repairs or renovations. This is because traditional lenders won't lend money on homes that don't meet their minimum property standards, but private lenders will lend money based on the property's value after repairs. Private financing may be better for unique or non-conforming properties, such as tiny homes, homes with land contract problems, or homes with unusual features that make traditional appraisal hard. Private mortgages are not the best option for primary residences in standard condition because the higher costs and shorter terms don't make sense when traditional financing is available and cheaper for long-term homeownership. The best type of property is one where the borrower has a clear plan to either raise the value of the property, stabilize their finances, or finish a project within the short loan term that private mortgages usually require.
To protect yourself from fraud or predatory lending, you need to take a few specific steps to make sure that a private lender is real. First, check to see if the lender needs a license in your state. Most states require mortgage lenders to keep their licenses up to date with their state banking or financial services department. You can check the status of a license on your state's regulatory website. You can look up the lender's name in the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's complaint database, your state attorney general's consumer protection division, and Better Business Bureau records to see if there are any complaints, enforcement actions, or legal problems. If you see a lot of complaints about bait-and-switch tactics, hidden fees, or borrowers who can't get in touch with the lender after closing, be careful. Before you agree to anything, a legitimate lender should give you clear, written proof of all the terms. This should include a detailed list of fees, interest rates, a payment schedule, and loan documents for your lawyer to look over. Some signs that something might be a scam are when they pressure you to act quickly without giving you time to do your research, ask for fees up front before the loan is approved, are hesitant to give you written terms or verifiable business information, make promises that seem too good to be true compared to other offers, or give you documents with blank spaces that you can fill in later. Always have an independent real estate lawyer look over all loan documents before you sign them. Also, get an independent property appraisal instead of just relying on the lender's valuation. If something seems off or too aggressive, trust your gut. Real private lenders know that borrowers who know what they're doing are better borrowers, so they won't pressure you to skip these steps.
It all depends on the terms of your loan agreement, especially the rules about prepayment penalties and early payoff conditions, whether you can get out of a private mortgage early. If you pay off a private mortgage before the term ends, you may have to pay a prepayment penalty. This is because the lender planned to make money on the loan for the full term and loses that money if you refinance or sell early. These fees usually range from 1% to 5% of the loan balance or the amount of interest that has built up over the course of several months. This can add thousands of dollars to the cost of paying off the loan. There are some private mortgages that don't charge you for paying off your loan early. This means you can refinance or sell whenever you want. This is why it's important to read the prepayment terms carefully before signing so you know what your options and costs will be if your situation changes. If you want to refinance as your way out, you should try to get as few or no prepayment penalties as possible so you can switch to traditional financing as soon as you can. If you think you might need to sell the property before the loan term ends, prepayment penalties could keep you from selling or make it less profitable. Always talk about prepayment terms before you sign a loan agreement, and make sure your lawyer looks over this part of the contract. If you think you might need some flexibility, some lenders will agree to drop or lower prepayment penalties in exchange for slightly higher interest rates. Before you take out a loan, it's important to know what your options are for getting out of it so you aren't surprised by fees or restrictions when you're ready to move on.
Different lenders have different requirements for private mortgages, and these requirements are usually less standard than those for traditional mortgages. However, you should be ready to provide several important types of documents to show that you can pay back the loan and that the property is worth enough to be used as collateral. Most private lenders will ask for proof of identity, like a driver's license or state ID and your Social Security number, so they can do basic background checks. If you're buying a property, they'll need proof of ownership, such as a purchase contract, the property's address and description, and recent photos showing how it looks now. When you apply for a loan, you usually need to show recent bank statements that show you have enough money for the down payment and closing costs, proof of income like pay stubs, bank statements, or tax returns. The requirements are more flexible than those of traditional lenders. If you already own the property, you may also need to show existing mortgage statements or property tax records. Before closing, some private lenders also want to see proof of homeowner's insurance or a promise to pay. Private lenders may accept a wider range of proof of financial ability than traditional lenders, who have set documentation checklists and require certain forms to be filled out in certain ways. A traditional lender might want two years of full tax returns from you if you work for yourself, but a private lender might be okay with six months of bank statements showing regular deposits. The most important thing is to be ready to show that you can make the payments and that the property that secures the loan is worth something. You should also know that each private lender may have different specific requirements based on how they assess risk.
Fact Checked