Trustpilot
Loading...
Loading...Loading...
After spending 17 years optimizing mortgage workflows at AmeriSave, I've watched how a thorough title examination saves borrowers from catastrophic financial exposure. The $150 you spend on a title search today can prevent $50,000 in legal fees tomorrow. That happens when someone emerges claiming ownership rights you never knew existed.
Back in 2016, we had a system outage that delayed title searches by three days across our entire Louisville processing center. My team pulled some serious overtime getting everything back on track. But that incident taught me something valuable. You can't rush due diligence. We've since built redundancies into our title examination workflows because this step protects everyone involved in the transaction.
When you make an offer on a house, you're operating on the assumption that the seller actually has the legal authority to transfer ownership to you. That sounds obvious, right? Property ownership is surprisingly complex though. Previous owners may have taken out loans using the property as collateral. Contractors may have filed mechanics liens for unpaid work. Tax authorities may have claims for delinquent payments. All of these encumbrances follow the property through subsequent sales unless they're properly cleared.
A title search digs through decades of public records to verify the chain of ownership and identify any claims against the property. Title abstractors examine county courthouse documents, tax assessor records, probate filings, divorce decrees, bankruptcy proceedings, and mortgage recordings to reconstruct the complete ownership history. This investigation typically reaches back 30 to 50 years, though some searches go further depending on when reliable records begin for that jurisdiction.
The process catches issues that could derail your purchase or haunt you for years after closing. I'm talking about forged deeds. Undisclosed heirs claiming inheritance rights. Survey boundary disputes with neighbors. Unpaid HOA assessments. IRS tax liens. Contractor mechanics liens. Utility easements that restrict land use. Environmental compliance violations. Any one of these problems can invalidate the seller's ability to convey clear title, leaving you without recourse if you've already completed the purchase.
The workflow breaks down like this: your lender orders the title search shortly after you go under contract, typically through a title company or real estate attorney. That professional examiner then spends hours reviewing public records to compile a complete ownership history. They're looking for gaps, inconsistencies, or red flags that suggest potential problems with the title.
Most buyers never see this work happening. The title search runs in the background while you're scheduling inspections and finalizing your mortgage approval. But that behind-the-scenes investigation provides crucial protection. According to industry data from the American Land Title Association, title insurance companies paid out $331.8 million in claims during the first six months of 2023 alone. This demonstrates how frequently title defects surface even after professional examination.
Lenders require title searches as a standard condition of mortgage approval. They won't fund your loan without verification that you're receiving marketable title to the property. This protects their collateral position, but it also protects you. Even if you're purchasing with cash and could technically skip the title search, that's playing with fire. The current owner might not even realize there's an old claim against the property sitting in county records.
I've seen situations where someone inherited a house from their parents, lived there for five years, then decided to sell. They discovered during the title search that their grandfather had taken out a second mortgage in 1987 that was never properly satisfied. The debt was technically still active. The original lender had been acquired by three different banks over the decades. Clearing that lien required tracking down corporate acquisition records and obtaining release documents from an institution that barely remembered the loan existed.
That kind of complexity explains why professional title examiners are worth their fees. They know which records to pull, how to interpret legal documents, and what constitutes a marketable title under local law. Different states have varying requirements for what must be disclosed and what defects can be waived. An examiner in Florida follows different procedures than one in Oregon, and both operate under state-specific regulations that govern title transfer.
The title search protects you from several categories of problems. Financial encumbrances include mortgages, home equity lines of credit, tax liens, judgment liens, mechanic's liens from contractors, and HOA special assessments. These debts attach to the property itself rather than the individual owner. Legal restrictions encompass easements allowing utility companies or neighbors to access portions of your property, restrictive covenants limiting how you can use the land, building code violations requiring remediation before sale, and zoning compliance issues affecting property improvements.
Ownership complications involve probate proceedings where estate heirs may contest the sale, divorce settlements that didn't properly divide property interests, forged or fraudulent deeds in the ownership chain, and missing documentation for past transfers. By identifying these problems before closing, you preserve your right to walk away from the purchase or negotiate with the seller to resolve the issues. Once you own the property, the burden shifts to you. That's when a $200 problem becomes a $20,000 legal battle.
Looking at our throughput metrics, the average title search requires 10 to 14 days from order to completion. That timeline accounts for requesting records from multiple county offices, reviewing documents that may span decades, and preparing a comprehensive abstract of title that summarizes the findings.
The title abstractor starts by identifying the current owner through recent deed recordings. They then work backward through successive transfers, verifying that each conveyance was properly executed and recorded. This creates the chain of title—a chronological history showing how ownership passed from person to person over time.
Several factors can extend the search timeline. Older properties with histories reaching back 80 or 100 years require examination of more records. Properties that changed hands frequently need additional verification at each transfer point. Jurisdictions with incomplete digital records may require in-person courthouse visits to access archived documents. Properties involved in estate settlements, divorces, or bankruptcies need review of court proceedings that may not be indexed in standard property databases.
Title search costs scale with property complexity. A basic single-family home built in 1995 typically runs $100 to $150 for a standard search covering 5 to 8 ownership transfers over 7 to 10 days. A historic home built in 1920 might cost $200 to $300 for an extended search examining 15 to 25 ownership transfers over 14 to 21 days. Commercial properties with multiple parcels can run $1,000 to $2,500 for comprehensive searches covering 30+ documents across 21 to 45 days.
The abstractor examines several specific record types during the investigation. Deed books document every property transfer and mortgage recording. Tax assessment rolls show payment history and outstanding obligations. Court records reveal judgments, liens, and legal proceedings affecting the property. Probate files identify estate transfers and potential heir claims. Survey maps establish boundaries and easements. Municipal records contain building permits, code violations, and zoning compliance documentation.
When we scaled this process at AmeriSave, we found that automation can speed up record retrieval but can't replace human judgment in interpreting documents. Some counties now offer online access to digitized records, which reduces the time abstractors spend traveling to courthouses. But someone still needs to review each document, understand its legal implications, and determine whether it affects the current title.
The title examination produces an abstract of title—basically a chronological summary of everything found in the public record. This document lists all owners, mortgages, liens, judgments, easements, and other encumbrances discovered during the search. The abstractor's goal is to determine whether the seller holds marketable title that can be legally transferred to you.
A "clean title" means the examination found no outstanding claims, liens, or legal obstacles to the sale. The seller owns the property free and clear, or subject only to the mortgage being paid off at closing. This is the outcome everyone wants because it allows the transaction to proceed without delays or complications.
A "clouded" or "dirty title" indicates problems that must be resolved before the sale can close. Common issues include unpaid property taxes, unsatisfied mortgage liens from previous owners, judgment liens from creditors, mechanic's liens from contractors claiming unpaid bills, tax liens from IRS or state revenue departments, unresolved estate matters where heirs may have ownership interests, and missing documentation for past transfers.
Most title defects can be fixed given enough time and cooperation. The seller typically bears responsibility for clearing clouds on their title before transferring ownership to you. They might need to pay off old debts, obtain lien releases from creditors who were satisfied decades ago but never filed the proper paperwork, correct errors in deed recordings, or settle legal disputes with other claimants.
Wait. Let me clarify something important here. Even the most thorough title search can miss hidden defects. Some problems simply don't show up in public records until years after your purchase. That's where title insurance becomes essential.
Title insurance is fundamentally different from other insurance products. You pay a one-time premium at closing rather than monthly or annual fees. The policy protects you against covered title defects for as long as you own the property, and in some cases even after you sell if claims arise regarding your period of ownership.
Two types of title insurance exist, and understanding the distinction matters. Lender's title insurance (also called a loan policy) protects your mortgage lender's financial interest in the property. Every lender requires this coverage as a condition of loan approval. The policy amount equals your mortgage balance and decreases as you pay down the loan. If a title defect causes the lender to lose their collateral position, the insurance reimburses their loss.
Owner's title insurance protects your equity in the property. This coverage is optional in most states, though some jurisdictions require it. The policy amount typically equals the purchase price and remains constant throughout your ownership. If someone successfully challenges your ownership or a covered lien surfaces, the insurance either defends your title in court or compensates you for your loss.
Lender's title insurance typically runs 0.5% to 1% of your loan amount. On a $400,000 mortgage, you'd pay roughly $2,000 to $4,000. Owner's title insurance adds a few hundred to a few thousand dollars depending on your purchase price and location. Many title companies offer bundled pricing where purchasing both policies together costs less than buying them separately.
According to data from the American Land Title Association, the title insurance industry generated $21 billion in premiums during 2022 across more than 6,500 member companies. That volume reflects the standard practice of requiring title insurance on nearly every residential mortgage transaction in the United States. The industry paid out hundreds of millions in claims that year. This demonstrates that title defects remain a real risk even with professional examination.
Title insurance covers several categories of problems that might not surface during the initial title search. Forgery and fraud includes forged deeds or mortgage releases, impersonation of property owners, and fraudulent documents in the chain of title. These are particularly insidious because they may not become apparent until someone challenges your ownership years later.
Undisclosed heirs covers situations where property passed through an estate, but heirs who should have inherited interests were never properly notified. They can emerge years later claiming rightful ownership based on probate irregularities. Errors in public records encompasses clerical mistakes in deed recordings, incorrect legal descriptions, and filing errors that create ambiguity about ownership or property boundaries.
Unknown liens includes tax liens that were filed but not properly indexed, judgment liens against previous owners with similar names, and mechanic's liens filed just before or after the title search but before closing. Easements and encroachments protects against undisclosed easements that restrict your land use and boundary disputes where structures encroach on neighboring property.
Title insurance provides coverage for defects that existed before your purchase but weren't discovered during the title search. It doesn't cover problems that arise after you take ownership, such as new liens filed against you or zoning violations you create. That's why the policy runs from the date of your purchase backward through the property's history.
When a title claim arises, you receive notice that someone is challenging your ownership or asserting a lien against the property. You immediately contact your title insurance company and provide them with the claim documentation. The insurer investigates the claim to determine whether it's covered under your policy. If covered, they either defend your title in court at their expense or pay the claim amount up to your policy limit.
The defense obligation is particularly valuable. Legal fees to contest a title claim can easily reach $50,000 or more depending on the complexity. Your title insurance company handles this at no additional cost beyond your original premium.
Looking at the numbers across different markets, title search fees show substantial geographic variation. New Jersey homebuyers pay anywhere from $87.95 for a basic ownership and encumbrance report to $320 or more for comprehensive searches including township lien checks and demolition records. California title searches typically run $150 to $250 for standard residential properties. Texas buyers see similar ranges, with complexity driving costs higher on older properties or those with complicated ownership histories.
State law and local custom determine who pays these expenses. In some markets, buyers bear the full cost of title examination and insurance. In others, sellers traditionally pay as part of their obligation to deliver clear title. Many states split the costs or make them subject to negotiation between the parties. Your purchase contract should specify exactly who's responsible for each title-related expense.
The expense breakdown for a typical $400,000 home purchase might look like this. Title search runs $150. Title examination and abstract costs $200. Lender's title insurance hits $2,400 (0.6% of loan amount). Owner's title insurance adds $1,600 (bundled discount). Title settlement fee is $300. Recording fees come to $125. Total title-related closing costs reach $4,775.
Those expenses amount to roughly 1.2% of the purchase price, which falls well within the normal range of 3% to 6% for total closing costs on a home purchase. When you consider that these fees protect you from potentially catastrophic financial losses, the cost-benefit analysis favors paying for proper title examination and insurance.
You'd improve your ROI by an enormous margin when you factor in risk avoidance. One undiscovered lien could cost you tens of thousands in legal fees and debt satisfaction. A successful ownership challenge could result in losing the property entirely. The modest upfront investment in title services provides asymmetric protection against tail risks that, while infrequent, carry severe consequences when they occur.
I've seen buyers balk at title insurance costs, especially cash purchasers who aren't subject to lender requirements. That's short-sighted thinking from a risk management perspective. You're making a six-figure investment in an asset with a complex legal history spanning decades. Spending an additional 1% to verify that history and insure against hidden defects is basic financial prudence.
Technically, yes, you can research property records yourself rather than hiring a title company or attorney. County courthouses, recorder's offices, and assessor's offices maintain public records that anyone can access. Many jurisdictions now offer online databases where you can search deed recordings, tax records, and some court filings from your home computer.
The practical reality is that DIY title searches rarely make sense. The process requires knowing which records to pull, where to find them, how to interpret legal documents, and what constitutes a clear title under your state's law. Missing a single lien or incorrectly reading a legal description can expose you to massive financial liability.
You'd need to identify the current owner and pull their deed recording from the county recorder's office. That deed references the previous owner, so you'd then pull their deed. You continue this process backward through the chain of title, typically needing to go back at least 30 years or to the last title insurance policy, whichever is more recent.
At each step, you're verifying that the deed was properly executed (signed, notarized, recorded), that the legal description matches the property, and that no discrepancies exist between successive transfers. You're also checking for mortgage recordings associated with each owner and verifying that those mortgages were subsequently satisfied and released.
Simultaneously, you need to search tax records to confirm all property taxes have been paid current. Delinquent taxes create liens that attach to the property. You also need to search judgment records to identify any court judgments against previous owners that might have created liens against the property.
Then there's probate court, where you check whether the property passed through any estates and whether those estates were properly settled. Divorce records matter too, since marital property divisions must be properly executed. Bankruptcy filings can complicate ownership and lien priority.
And that's just scratching the surface. You haven't yet looked for mechanic's liens from contractors, HOA liens for unpaid assessments, utility easements, recorded covenants and restrictions, or survey discrepancies affecting property boundaries.
The time investment alone makes professional title services worthwhile. A comprehensive title search can require 20 to 40 hours of work depending on property complexity. You're paying a title professional $5 to $10 per hour when you hire someone at $200 for a standard search. That's incredibly efficient compared to spending days or weeks navigating unfamiliar record systems and legal documents.
The knowledge gap poses an even bigger problem. Title examiners spend years developing expertise in property law, document interpretation, and local recording practices. They know what they're looking for and how to spot red flags that might escape an amateur's notice. Missing a critical document or misinterpreting a legal description can leave you with a property you thought was clean but actually carries hidden encumbrances.
Most importantly, when you hire a title company or attorney, they carry professional liability insurance. If their examination misses a defect that should have been discovered, you have legal recourse. When you do your own title search and miss something, you bear the full consequences with no one to sue for recovery.
The exception might be if you're researching property ownership for informational purposes rather than actual purchase. Want to know who owns the vacant lot next door? A quick search of online county records can probably answer that question without professional help. Considering making an offer on a house? That's when you need trained professionals examining the title.
The bottleneck was always in resolving title defects discovered during examination. A clean title proceeds to closing without delays. A clouded title requires remediation that can extend your closing timeline by weeks or even months depending on the severity.
Clerical errors like misspelled names, incorrect legal descriptions, or filing mistakes can usually be fixed in 1 to 2 weeks by filing corrective documents with the county recorder. Unsatisfied mortgages where the loan was paid off but the lender never filed a release require tracking down the original lender or their successor. This can take 2 to 6 weeks depending on how many times the lender has been acquired or merged.
Property tax liens need payment in full plus any accumulated penalties and interest. Settlement timing depends on whether funds are immediately available and how quickly the tax authority processes payments—typically 1 to 3 weeks. Judgment liens from court cases must be satisfied or released by the creditor. If the judgment creditor can't be located or refuses to cooperate, you may need court proceedings to clear the lien—potentially 30 to 90 days or longer.
Mechanics liens from contractors claiming unpaid work require either payment or proof that the lien was improperly filed. Disputed mechanic's liens can drag into litigation for 3 to 12 months. Boundary disputes with neighbors may require new surveys, negotiated easements, or lot line adjustments over 30 to 180 days depending on complexity and cooperation levels.
Estate and probate issues where ownership isn't clearly established may require probate proceedings or agreements among heirs. These can take 60 days to 2 years depending on family cooperation and court backlogs.
Title searches should be ordered immediately after going under contract rather than waiting until just before closing. The sooner you know about title defects, the more time you have to resolve them without blowing your closing deadline.
Most purchase contracts include contingencies allowing you to walk away if title can't be cleared within a reasonable timeframe. That protects your earnest money deposit and prevents you from being forced to close on a property with known title problems. But exercising that contingency means starting your home search over, so most buyers prefer to work through title issues if they can be reasonably resolved.
The seller bears legal responsibility for delivering marketable title at closing. If they can't clear title defects, you're not obligated to proceed with the purchase. That's a crucial protection because it means title problems are fundamentally the seller's problem to fix, not yours.
While most people associate title searches with home purchases, they're also required in several other contexts. Each situation brings unique challenges and considerations.
Refinancing your existing mortgage requires a new title search even though you already own the property. Lenders want to verify that no new liens or claims have been filed since your original purchase. The good news is that refinance title searches are usually faster and less expensive than purchase title searches because they only need to cover the period since your last financing. Expect to pay $75 to $150 and wait 5 to 7 days.
Estate settlements where property transfers to heirs require comprehensive title examination to ensure the deceased owner held clear title and that the probate process properly conveyed ownership to beneficiaries. These searches often uncover complications because the property may have been owned for decades without any title examination. Estates may also involve multiple heirs with fractional interests that need to be consolidated or divided.
Commercial properties demand far more extensive title searches due to their complexity and value. A commercial property might include multiple parcels, complicated easements, environmental compliance issues, zoning restrictions, and extensive lien histories. Commercial title searches routinely cost $1,000 to $5,000 and can take 30 to 60 days. The title insurance policies on commercial properties also carry significantly higher premiums due to the increased risk and policy limits.
Foreclosure purchases bring particularly challenging title issues. The foreclosure process is supposed to extinguish junior liens, but procedural defects in foreclosure proceedings can leave those liens in place. Purchasing foreclosed properties requires extremely careful title examination and strong title insurance coverage.
Tax deed sales where properties are sold for delinquent taxes can convey property with highly questionable title. Some states require waiting periods before clean title can be established. These purchases are for sophisticated investors only, not typical homebuyers.
Once the title examination is complete, you'll receive a title commitment (also called a preliminary title report in some states). This document outlines what the title company is willing to insure and under what conditions.
The title commitment contains several critical sections. Schedule A identifies the property, the proposed insured parties, and the policy amount. Schedule B-I lists requirements that must be satisfied before the title company will issue the policy—typically things like paying off existing mortgages, obtaining releases for liens, and recording your new deed. Schedule B-II lists exceptions to coverage—defects that the title company discovered but won't insure against.
Those Schedule B-II exceptions deserve close scrutiny. Standard exceptions include matters that would be revealed by physical inspection or survey, unrecorded easements or encroachments, and mineral rights reservations in certain states. Some exceptions can be removed if you provide additional documentation or purchase extended coverage.
Read your title commitment carefully and ask questions about anything you don't understand. This is your last opportunity to identify title problems before closing. Once you accept the title commitment and close on the property, you've agreed to take ownership subject to all listed exceptions.
At AmeriSave, we've built relationships with reputable title companies in every market we serve. When you apply for a mortgage with us, we automatically order your title search from one of our vetted partners as soon as your contract is accepted.
Our system tracks the title examination progress and alerts our processing team to any issues that surface. If the title comes back with defects, we work with you and the title company to develop a remediation plan that keeps your closing on schedule.
The integration between our loan origination system and the title companies' platforms allows real-time status updates. You can log into your AmeriSave account and see exactly where your title search stands at any point in the process. That transparency reduces stress and keeps everyone aligned on timing.
We also negotiate competitive title insurance rates on behalf of our borrowers. Because we generate significant volume with our title partners, we can pass along favorable pricing that individual borrowers typically can't access on their own. This can save you hundreds of dollars compared to shopping for title services independently.
American Land Title Association. (2023). Industry financial data. Retrieved from https://www.alta.org/
American Land Title Association. (2022). Title insurance industry statistics. Retrieved from https://www.alta.org/
When title examination uncovers defects, the process pauses while the seller works to clear the clouds on their title. Common problems like unpaid liens or missing documentation can usually be resolved in a few weeks. Complex issues may take months. The seller bears responsibility for fixing title defects since they're required to deliver clear title at closing. If they can't resolve the problems within a reasonable timeframe, you have the right to terminate the purchase contract and recover your earnest money deposit.
Most purchase agreements include specific contingency language protecting buyers from being forced to close on property with known title issues. Your real estate agent and attorney can advise you on whether to wait for remediation or move on to another property. In rare cases where you want to proceed despite title problems, you might negotiate price reductions or other concessions from the seller to compensate for the added risk. Some buyers accept properties with minor title clouds if they're confident about resolving them after purchase. This approach requires sophisticated understanding of real estate law and should only be attempted with experienced legal counsel.
The title company may refuse to insure certain defects. This means you'd proceed without coverage for those specific problems while still maintaining insurance against other potential issues. It creates a hybrid situation where you're partially protected but assuming risk on known defects that couldn't be cleared before closing.
You need both. The reason is they serve different but complementary purposes. The title search is a point-in-time examination of public records to identify known defects. It's a research process that attempts to uncover existing problems before you purchase. Title insurance protects you against defects that weren't discovered during the title search due to recording errors, fraud, missing documents, or other issues that can't be detected through public record examination alone.
Think of it this way. The title search tells you what's wrong now so you can fix it before buying. Title insurance protects you from what might be wrong but nobody knows about yet. You could theoretically skip title insurance if you're a cash buyer. That's incredibly risky though. You should never skip the title search itself because buying property with known defects that you could have discovered is just asking for trouble.
Most mortgage lenders require both title examination and title insurance as standard underwriting conditions. They won't fund your loan without verification that you're receiving marketable title and without insurance protecting their collateral position. Even if you're paying cash and could technically avoid these expenses, doing so exposes you to catastrophic financial risk for relatively modest savings. The $200 you save by skipping the title search could cost you $50,000 when an undiscovered lien surfaces two years after purchase. That's terrible risk-adjusted return on your decision to cut corners.
Most residential title searches examine records going back 30 to 50 years or to the last title insurance policy, whichever provides sufficient coverage. The timeframe matters because claims against property can remain enforceable for decades if they were never properly resolved. A mechanics lien from 1985 might still be valid if it was never released or satisfied.
The concept of "marketable title" varies by state. Some jurisdictions establish specific statutory periods beyond which old defects can be disregarded. These marketable title acts typically set 30, 40, or 50-year windows for claims. Anything older than the statutory period is presumed extinguished unless specific exceptions apply. But even in states with marketable title acts, examiners routinely search beyond the statutory period to verify there aren't complications requiring special handling.
Older properties naturally require more extensive searches because they've had more owners and more opportunities for problems to develop. A house built in 1890 might have 15 to 20 ownership transfers, multiple mortgage recordings, estate settlements, and decades of tax records to examine. Each transfer point brings a potential break in the chain of title or introduction of new encumbrances. That's why title searches on historic properties often cost more and take longer than searches on newer construction.
Properties with recent construction may have simpler title histories but can bring different challenges. New subdivisions require verification that the developer properly established lots, dedicated roads and utilities, and satisfied all mechanics liens from contractors. The first buyer is essentially accepting title that flows from the developer. The developer assembled the land from previous owners, obtained subdivision approval, completed infrastructure improvements, and created individual lots for sale.
These are related concepts but describe different components of title examination. The title search is the investigative process where professionals examine public records to reconstruct ownership history and identify potential problems. It's the action of conducting research, not a document itself.
The abstract of title is the written report produced by the title search. It summarizes all relevant documents found in public records, presented in chronological order. The abstract includes deeds, mortgages, liens, judgments, easements, and other recorded instruments affecting the property. Think of it as the comprehensive reference document that captures everything discovered during the search process. An abstract might be 50 to 100 pages for a property with a long history.
The chain of title is one component within the abstract. It's specifically the sequence of ownership transfers showing how title passed from person to person over time. It verifies that each conveyance was properly executed and that there are no gaps or breaks in the ownership sequence. A break in the chain of title occurs when a deed references the wrong previous owner, creating doubt about whether the property was legally conveyed.
You hire someone to conduct a title search. They produce an abstract of title documenting their findings. Within that abstract, you'll find the chain of title showing the ownership history. The title company then evaluates the abstract to determine whether they'll issue title insurance and under what conditions. All of these steps work together to give you confidence that you're buying property with clear, marketable title.
Generally yes on both counts, though it depends on the property's specific history and the efficiency of local record-keeping. Older properties have had more owners, more financial transactions, and more opportunities for complications to develop. A house built in 1890 might have 20 ownership transfers to examine, while a house built in 2015 might only have two or three.
Each additional transfer point requires the title examiner to pull and review documents, verify proper execution, and check for liens or judgments that might have attached during that owner's period of ownership. More owners means more probate proceedings to investigate, more divorces to check for property division issues, and more mortgage recordings to verify were properly satisfied.
The age and organization of public records also affects search timeline. Counties that have digitized their records back to the 1970s allow examiners to work much faster than counties where pre-1990 records exist only on microfilm or in physical deed books stored at the courthouse. Some rural counties still require in-person visits to examine records, adding travel time and access limitations to the process.
A well-maintained property with clean title can sometimes be examined quickly even if it's old. If the property passed through just a few owners who maintained good records, carried title insurance, and resolved all liens promptly, the search may not take significantly longer than for a newer property. Conversely, a newer property with complicated ownership—perhaps passing through an estate, a divorce, and a foreclosure in just ten years—could require more investigation than a stable older property.
Budget an extra $50 to $100 for title searches on homes built before 1960, and expect the process to take a few extra days. Your title company can provide estimates once they know the property address and can assess the likely scope of examination required.
Sometimes yes, sometimes no. It depends on the nature of the problem and how it was disclosed. If a title defect existed before your purchase but wasn't discovered during the title search, your title insurance should cover resolution costs up to your policy limits. The insurance company will either defend your title in court or pay valid claims against the property.
If you want to clear a known defect that wasn't covered by your title insurance, you'll need to handle it yourself. This might involve paying off old liens, obtaining releases from creditors, or pursuing quiet title actions in court. Quiet title lawsuits ask a judge to formally declare that your title is clear of specific claimed interests. These proceedings can take months or years and cost thousands in legal fees.
Some title problems are practically impossible to fix after purchase. For example, if someone successfully proves they have superior ownership rights to the property based on a defect deep in the chain of title, you could potentially lose the property entirely. That's catastrophic. That's why title insurance exists to protect you from that scenario. The insurance company would compensate you for your loss up to the policy amount.
Easements and restrictions that run with the land generally can't be removed after purchase unless you negotiate releases from the parties who benefit from them. If your neighbor has a recorded easement allowing access across your property, that easement typically remains in effect regardless of ownership changes. You'd need to negotiate with the easement holder and pay them to release their interest if you wanted to eliminate it.
That's short-sighted thinking from a risk management perspective. Title insurance costs roughly 0.5% to 1% of your purchase price as a one-time premium. For a $400,000 property, you're looking at maybe $2,000 to $4,000. That protects you from potentially catastrophic losses if someone successfully challenges your ownership or if undiscovered liens surface after your purchase.
The math strongly favors buying title insurance even when you're not required to. Yes, title claims are relatively infrequent—most properties don't have serious defects that weren't caught during the title search. But when claims do occur, they can easily reach five or six figures in legal fees and potential loss of the property. You're buying insurance against tail risk events that could wipe out your entire investment.
Cash buyers sometimes rationalize that they've saved money by avoiding lender requirements and don't want to add back expenses. But skipping title insurance to save $3,000 on a $400,000 purchase is accepting massive downside risk for trivial savings. If there's even a 1% chance of a title claim averaging $50,000, the expected value of insurance is $500. That makes a $3,000 premium expensive but not unreasonable given the catastrophic scenario it protects against.
Consider too that title insurance makes your property more marketable when you eventually sell. Future buyers will have confidence that your ownership was properly insured, creating a cleaner chain of title for their own purchase. Properties without title insurance in the ownership history may raise questions during subsequent title examinations.
Then you typically have the right to walk away from the purchase and recover your earnest money deposit. Standard purchase contracts include title contingencies requiring the seller to deliver marketable title at closing. If they can't or won't clear discovered defects, you're not obligated to proceed.
The seller might refuse to fix title problems if they're expensive to resolve or if they dispute whether the problems are actually defects requiring remediation. In that case, you need to decide whether you're willing to take the property with known issues, possibly at a reduced price, or whether you'd rather find a different property without complications.
Some buyers will proceed with known title defects if they're minor and they're confident about resolving them after purchase. For example, if the only issue is tracking down a satisfaction of mortgage that was clearly paid off in 1995, you might agree to close and handle that cleanup yourself in exchange for a price reduction. But this approach requires sophisticated understanding of real estate law and acceptance of risk that might prove more complicated than expected.
Most buyers prefer to walk away rather than accept properties with unresolved title problems. There are plenty of houses available without these complications. So why take on extra risk and hassle? The time invested in your purchase up to that point is a sunk cost. Don't compound it by making a bad purchase decision just because you've already committed time and energy.
Standard title insurance policies cover most common defects but include certain standard exceptions. Extended coverage (sometimes called ALTA homeowner's policies) removes many standard exceptions and adds protection for issues like post-policy forgery, forced removal of structures due to violations, and mechanic's liens for work done before your purchase but recorded after.
Whether extended coverage is worth the additional premium depends on your property and risk tolerance. Properties in stable neighborhoods with clear title histories probably don't need extended coverage. Properties with complicated improvements, potential boundary issues, or recent construction might benefit from the additional protection.
Review your title commitment carefully to understand what's excluded from coverage. If the exclusions concern you, discuss expanded coverage options with your title company. The additional premium for extended coverage typically runs $100 to $300—a modest increase for substantially broader protection.
Also verify that your policy amount equals your purchase price. Title insurance doesn't increase with property value appreciation, so the coverage you bought ten years ago might not fully protect your current equity. Some policies offer inflation protection that automatically increases coverage over time, but many don't. If your property has appreciated significantly, consider purchasing additional coverage to protect your increased investment.
Then you have a potential claim for professional negligence against the title company. Title companies carry errors and omissions insurance to protect against situations where their examination failed to uncover discoverable defects. If you can prove that a competent title examiner should have found the problem and that the company's failure to do so caused you financial harm, you may be able to recover damages.
The challenge is establishing that the defect was actually discoverable through reasonable examination. Some title problems genuinely can't be found in public records—forged documents, impersonation of owners, unrecorded interests—and those are what title insurance exists to cover. But if a lien was properly recorded in the county index and the examiner simply didn't pull that record, that's potentially negligent examination.
Your title insurance should cover you regardless of whether the missed defect was the title company's fault. The insurance provides protection whether defects were undiscoverable or whether they resulted from examination errors. You generally don't need to pursue a negligence claim against the title company because the insurance resolves your loss. If you're dissatisfied with the insurance settlement, that's when you might consider legal action against the title company.
This is another reason why using reputable, established title companies matters. Large, well-capitalized title companies have the resources to handle claims and the incentive to maintain their reputation. Using a cut-rate title service to save $50 on your title search could leave you with inadequate protection if problems emerge.
Fact Checked