Trustpilot
Loading...
Loading...Loading...
Look, I've been in this business since I was 18 and I can't tell you how many phone calls I get from panicked buyers who just found out their dream home failed the FHA appraisal. They've already picked out paint colors, told their kids about the backyard, and then boom—the appraiser flags peeling paint or a questionable roof.
The FHA minimum property standards aren't there to ruin your day. They protect you from buying a house that could drain your bank account or put your family at risk. When you're putting down just 3.5% (all FHA requires if your credit score is 580 or above per HUD Handbook 4000.1, accessed October 2025 from https://www.hud.gov/program_offices/housing/sfh/handbook_4000-1), the lender needs assurance the property securing your mortgage has real value.
According to HUD's Financial Status of the FHA Mutual Mortgage Insurance Fund FY 2024 (accessed October 2025 from https://www.hud.gov/sites/dfiles/Housing/documents/2024FHAAnnualReportMMIFund.pdf), FHA endorsed 580,000 home purchase mortgages in fiscal year 2023, with over 82% going to first-time home buyers. That's a massive number of people relying on these standards to make homeownership accessible and safe.
Every FHA property must meet three fundamental standards defined by the Department of Housing and Urban Development:
Safety: The house must provide a safe and healthy environment. This covers proper electrical systems, functioning heat and hot water, no lead hazards, and adequate ventilation.
Security: The property needs to offer protection to occupants, including working locks, structural integrity, and protection from the elements.
Soundness: The home can't have structural defects compromising its integrity—no foundation problems, major roof damage, or framing issues.
According to 24 CFR Part 200 Subpart S (accessed October 2025 from https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-24/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-200/subpart-S), all housing constructed under HUD mortgage insurance programs must meet or exceed these minimum property standards without exception.
When you apply for an FHA loan, your lender orders an appraisal from a HUD-approved appraiser. You pay for this—typically $300-600—and the appraiser performs two distinct jobs:
The appraiser establishes the home's current market value by comparing it to similar homes (comparable sales or "comps") that sold recently in the area. For a 1,800 square foot ranch, they'll find other ranches with similar square footage that sold in the past 3-6 months.
Here's how a basic valuation works:
Sample Property: 1,800 sq ft, 3BR/2BA, built 1985, purchase price $255,000
Comp #1: 1,750 sq ft, sold $245,000 (+$2,000 adjustment for smaller size)
Comp #2: 1,850 sq ft, sold $252,000 (-$2,000 adjustment for larger size)
Comp #3: 1,800 sq ft, sold $248,000 (no adjustment needed)
Adjusted Values: $247,000 / $250,000 / $248,000
Final Appraised Value: $248,000
Problem: Purchase price ($255,000) exceeds appraised value by $7,000
Solution needed: Make up difference, renegotiate, or walk away
If the home appraises below your offer price, the lender won't loan more than the appraised amount.
The appraiser walks through the property examining everything against HUD's minimum requirements. They document findings on the Uniform Residential Appraisal Report (Fannie Mae Form 1004/Freddie Mac Form 70).
According to the HUD Appraisal Report and Data Delivery Guide issued May 20, 2024 (accessed October 2025 from https://www.hud.gov/sites/dfiles/SFH/documents/SFH_POLI_APPR_RPT_FIN.pdf), this form requires detailed data entry covering everything from attic access to basement conditions to annual real estate taxes.
The appraisal is valid for 180 days from the effective date. If issues are found, they must be addressed before the loan can close.
Your home's interior must meet specific standards for systems, safety, and habitability.
HVAC, electrical, and water systems must function properly. The appraiser documents the heat source type and verifies it works. Electrical systems need proper grounding, no exposed wiring, and functional outlets. Water heaters must provide hot water to all fixtures.
For homes built before January 1, 1978, any chipping or peeling paint must be addressed before closing. This comes from HUD's lead-based paint regulations in Handbook 4000.1. Lead paint poses genuine health risks, especially for young children, potentially causing permanent developmental damage.
Sellers must either remove all loose paint, have it stabilized by a certified abatement professional, or provide documentation of completed work.
Handrails: Any staircase with three or more steps (interior or exterior) must have handrails. This is probably the most common failure point. Falls cause major injuries in homes, and this simple requirement protects occupants.
Basement and Crawl Space: Must be well-ventilated with no moisture, termite damage, or structural concerns. Standing water or visible damage requires remediation before loan approval.
Bathrooms: All fixtures (sinks, toilets, tubs, showers) must function properly with hot water available and adequate ventilation through exhaust fans or windows.
The home's exterior receives equally thorough scrutiny from the appraiser.
The roof must have at least 2 years of remaining useful life according to HUD minimum property standards. Appraisers check for holes, loose or missing shingles, proper connections to gutters and downspouts, and adequate flashing around chimneys and vents.
Determining "2 years of life" involves some judgment. If the roof shows curling shingles, extensive granule loss, or multiple visible layers, the appraiser may call for a professional roof inspection. If replacement is needed, here's what that typically costs (and honestly this is where negotiations get real):
Example: 1,800 sq ft home with asphalt shingle roof
1,800 sq ft ÷ 100 = 18 squares (roofing measured in 100 sq ft units)
Typical roof pitch adds 15-20% to square footage
18 squares × 1.175 (pitch factor) = 21.15 squares
21.15 squares × $450 per square = $9,517.50
Estimated total cost: $9,500-$10,500
Roof issues become major negotiation points between buyers and sellers.
The foundation must have proper grading (ground slopes away from the house), no major cracks or settling signs, no water pooling issues, and compliance with local building codes. According to 24 CFR 200.926c, when FHA standards conflict with local codes, the HUD Field Office resolves the conflict and the home must meet both requirements.
The home needs sufficient access to a public street or private road. Access must be year-round passable, legally documented with proper easements if crossing other land, and safe for vehicles.
Starting January 1, 2025, new construction in Special Flood Hazard Areas (SFHAs) must have the lowest floor at least two feet above base flood elevation. This requirement comes from HUD's Federal Flood Risk Management Standard implementation.
According to an article from floods.org published August 22, 2024 (accessed October 2025 from https://www.floods.org/news-views/from-the-directors-desk/three-things-to-know-about-new-hud-ffrms-rule/), this 2-foot freeboard requirement protects borrowers (especially first-time buyers) from flood damage risks. With FHA endorsing $208 billion in forward mortgages in FY 2023, protecting that investment makes financial sense.
This requirement applies only to new construction in flood zones. Existing homes in SFHAs follow standard requirements plus mandatory flood insurance.
FHA standards apply to different property types with variations.
Single-Family Homes: Standard Uniform Residential Appraisal Report (Form 1004/70)
Multifamily Properties (2-4 units): Fannie Mae Form 1025 or Freddie Mac Form 72, with each unit meeting habitability standards
Manufactured Homes: Forms 1004C/70B, with additional foundation requirements. According to HUD resources (https://www.hud.gov/hud-partners/minimum-property-standards-resources, accessed October 2025), manufactured homes need permanent foundations per the September 1996 Permanent Foundations Guide
Condominiums: Forms 1073/465, with added complexity around common areas and HOA requirements. The entire condo project must be FHA-approved or meet specific single-unit approval criteria
When a home doesn't meet minimum standards, the appraisal report details specific "conditions" or required repairs. You have several options.
Option 1: Seller Completes Repairs - Most common solution. The purchase contract gets amended requiring the seller to fix issues before closing. Repairs must be done by licensed professionals, documented with receipts, and often re-inspected.
Option 2: Repair Escrow - Money held at closing (1.5 times estimated repair cost) specifically for completing repairs after you take ownership. HUD strictly limits this—health and safety issues typically must be fixed before closing.
Option 3: You Pay for Repairs - You agree to handle repairs yourself, taking on expense and hassle that maybe should be the seller's responsibility.
Option 4: Walk Away - If repairs are extensive and the seller won't negotiate, walking away might be the smartest financial decision. The appraisal "follows the property" for 120 days, meaning other FHA buyers will face the same issues.
At AmeriSave, we help borrowers navigate these situations regularly. Our loan officers have seen every scenario and can help you evaluate options and make decisions that protect your interests.
Conventional loans have property requirements too, but they're often less strict. With conventional loans, appraisers primarily focus on market value, noting major defects but not flagging minor issues like missing handrails that would stop an FHA loan.
However, conventional loans typically require higher down payments (5-20% depending on credit and program) and PMI if you put down less than 20%. According to NAR's 2024 Home Buyers and Sellers Generational Trends Report (referenced at https://admortgage.com/blog/homebuyer-statistics-2024/, accessed October 2025), first-time home buyers had a median down payment of just 9% while repeat buyers put down 23%.
That lower FHA down payment requirement (3.5%) makes homeownership accessible, especially for first-time buyers. The property standards are the tradeoff, but they protect you from buying problem properties.
The FHA appraisal is not a home inspection. According to FHA Home Appraisal Guidelines for 2025 (http://fhahandbook.com/appraisal-guidelines.php, accessed October 2025), appraisals estimate value and check minimum standards but aren't comprehensive system evaluations.
Home inspectors spend 2-4 hours examining everything: electrical in detail, plumbing including drain lines, HVAC efficiency and remaining lifespan, roof underlayment and ventilation, structural components, insulation, windows, doors, grading, drainage, and potential pest issues. They produce detailed 30-50 page reports describing every major component's condition.
The appraisal might pass an HVAC system that functions currently, but the inspector would note it's 18 years old (past typical 12-15 year lifespan) and could fail soon. Or the appraisal might not flag an undersized electrical panel, but the inspector catches it.
Get both. The appraisal is mandatory anyway, and the inspection is inexpensive protection from expensive surprises. The inspection report also becomes a negotiating tool for addressing issues the seller should fix.
HUD has actively updated appraisal policies to address bias and discrimination. According to an article from fha.com published May 12, 2024 (accessed October 2025 from https://www.fha.com/fha_article?id=3810), HUD strengthened Nondiscrimination Policy and Appraiser Conduct requirements to promote equity.
Changes include enhanced competency requirements for appraisers, clearer guidelines for contesting appraisals or requesting reconsideration of value (ROV), and specific policies to eliminate racial, ethnic, or national origin bias in valuations.
Additionally, HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-18 issued in late June 2025 (referenced at https://www.fha.com/fha_article?id=4078, accessed October 2025) announced FHA was relaxing some extensive appraisal protocols, moving toward alignment with conventional standards while maintaining core safety, security, and soundness requirements.
FHA Appraisal: $300-$600, paid by buyer at or before closing
Home Inspection: $300-$500 for standard homes, up to $600+ for larger properties
FHA down payment is just 3.5% for credit scores 580+ per https://www.fhamortgagesource.com/2015-fha-qualifying-guidelines/ (accessed October 2025). For a $250,000 home:
Down payment: $250,000 × 3.5% = $8,750
Loan amount: $250,000 - $8,750 = $241,250
Upfront MIP: $241,250 × 1.75% = $4,221.88 (can be financed into loan)
New loan amount: $241,250 + $4,221.88 = $245,471.88
Plus, annual mortgage insurance (0.45%-1.05% of loan amount) paid monthly.
FHA minimum property standards can feel frustrating when they delay closings or kill deals. But they've saved more buyers from bad decisions than I can count. These standards ensure you're buying a home that's safe, structurally sound, and won't immediately drain your savings with emergency repairs.
When you're ready to start your FHA loan application:
The FHA program makes homeownership accessible to people who might otherwise struggle to buy. These property standards protect you during what's likely the biggest financial transaction of your life. At AmeriSave, we specialize in helping first-time home buyers navigate FHA loans and property standards, ensuring you close on a home that's both affordable and sound.
What do you mean by "fixer-upper"? Yes, you can use a regular FHA loan if the house needs cosmetic updates like new paint, new flooring, or new fixtures. The property only needs working heat, hot water, and electricity, a roof that will last at least two years, no major problems with the foundation, and no health and safety risks like lead paint or missing handrails. It's okay to have cosmetic problems.
If the house needs major structural work, a new roof, major electrical or plumbing repairs, or any other work that goes against FHA minimum property standards, a standard FHA loan won't work. FHA has the 203(k) Rehabilitation Loan for those situations. It combines the money to buy a home and the money to fix it up into one mortgage. The 203(k) can pay for everything from fixing up the structure to completely remodeling it, but it requires contractors, detailed plans, and extra supervision. We help borrowers at AmeriSave figure out if a standard FHA or 203(k) loan is right for them.
If the FHA appraisal doesn't go well, the appraiser's report lists the specific repairs or "conditions" that need to be made. You have a lot of choices. First, ask the seller to finish all the repairs that need to be done before the sale. This is the most common thing to do. Licensed professionals, receipts, and sometimes a second inspection are needed for repairs. Second, set up a repair escrow where money is held at closing (1.5 times the estimated cost of repairs) to pay for repairs after you buy the house. However, health and safety issues usually can't be put off. Third, agree to do the repairs yourself, which will cost you money and time. Fourth, if the seller won't fix major problems, you should walk away from the deal. The appraisal "follows the property" for 120 days, which means that other FHA buyers have to make the same repairs. This often makes sellers want to negotiate instead of letting deals fall through.
Yes, but there are some differences. All FHA-insured loans, whether they are for buying a home, refinancing, or getting a reverse mortgage, must meet the FHA's basic safety, security, and soundness standards. But the exact forms and requirements depend on the type of property. The Uniform Residential Appraisal Report is used for single-family homes. For 2-4 unit properties, condos, and manufactured homes, there are different forms and some extra standards. FHA 203(k) Rehabilitation Loans are only for properties that don't meet standards. Appraisals take into account the value of the property after planned improvements. FHA Streamline Refinances don't always need new appraisals, but lenders may order them anyway. There are also geographic and climate factors to think about. The new flood zone requirements that go into effect on January 1, 2025, only apply to new construction in Special Flood Hazard Areas. Heating requirements vary by climate, and air conditioning isn't always required, but it does affect value in hot markets.
There are a number of parts to the FHA appraisal timeline that can change when you close. The appraiser sets up a visit to the property after your lender orders the appraisal, which usually happens within a few days of your loan application. In normal markets, this happens within 3 to 7 days; in busy seasons or areas where there aren't enough appraisers, it can take 1 to 2 weeks. The actual visit to the property lasts between 45 minutes and a few hours, depending on how big and complicated it is. The appraiser looks up sales of similar properties and writes the report after the site visit. This usually takes 7 to 10 business days, but it could take up to two weeks for complicated properties or busy markets. After that, the report goes through your lender's underwriting review, which takes another 2–3 days. The whole process, from placing the order to getting the final report, usually takes 10 to 14 days. If there are delays, it could take up to 3 weeks. If repairs are needed, the timeline gets a lot longer while the seller does the work, provides proof, and verification happens. This can add anywhere from one week to a month or more, depending on how big the repairs are. Make sure to leave extra time in your schedule, and don't hire movers until you have a clear closing date and an appraisal that has been approved.
Yes, you can get an FHA loan on a property that has a private well or septic system, but there are some extra rules that apply. Water must be tested to make sure it is safe for properties with wells. To make sure the water won't make you sick, HUD says it needs to be tested for bacteria, nitrates, and lead. You hire a certified lab to do the tests, and the results must show that the water is safe to drink according to EPA standards. The well must be in the right place, far away from things that could pollute it, like septic systems, animal pens, or places where chemicals are stored. The appraiser checks to see if the septic system works properly and is big enough for the house. Before a loan can be approved, any signs of failure, such as standing water in the drain field, backup problems, strong smells, or visible surface discharge, must be fixed. The appraiser usually needs a qualified professional to check the septic system to make sure it works properly and to guess how much longer it will last. HUD Handbook 4940.3 on Minimum Design Standards for Community Sewerage Systems (https://www.hud.gov/hud-partners/minimum-property-standards-resources, accessed October 2025) says that septic systems must meet certain functional standards. The buyer usually pays for these inspections, which cost a few hundred dollars for water testing and $300 to $500 for a septic inspection. However, the buyer can sometimes negotiate the price.
A home inspection and an FHA appraisal are two completely different services with different goals. Your lender needs the FHA appraisal, which has two main goals: to find out the property's current market value and to make sure it meets FHA minimum safety, security, and soundness standards. The appraiser looks at your target home and compares it to similar homes that have recently sold. They check things like whether the roof has two years of life left, whether there is chipped lead paint, whether there are handrails, whether the major systems work, and whether the foundation is sound. They spend between 45 minutes and 2 hours at the property looking for FHA standard violations or problems with the market value. The appraisal is required for closing and costs between $300 and $600.
A licensed inspector does a full evaluation of all the systems and parts of the house in 2 to 4 hours. A home inspection is not required, but it is highly recommended. They look closely at the plumbing, including the drain lines, the HVAC system's efficiency and remaining lifespan, the roof's underlayment and ventilation, the building's structure, insulation, windows, doors, grading, drainage, and any possible pest problems. The inspector writes a 30-50 page report that goes into great detail about the condition of each major part and notes anything that is broken, damaged, near the end of its useful life, or could be a problem. The inspection costs $300 to $500 and is done for your benefit as the buyer. The main difference is that the appraisal is a pass/fail test on minimum standards, while the inspection gives you information that helps you make smart choices. Get both. The appraisal is required anyway, and the inspection is a cheap way to protect yourself from costly surprises.
Yes, condos have their own FHA rules that can sometimes cause problems that you didn't expect. The whole condo project must be FHA-approved or meet certain requirements for single-unit approval in order for the condo to be eligible for FHA financing. HUD keeps a list of condo projects that have been approved by the FHA. If your target project is on that list, it meets the FHA's minimum property standards. If the project isn't approved, though, you might be able to get "single-unit approval," which is more limited and doesn't work for all projects.
The condo project must meet certain standards, such as having an owner-occupancy ratio of at least 50% (meaning that at least half of the units are owner-occupied instead of rented), having enough insurance, having a properly functioning HOA with enough reserves, not having any major deferred maintenance, and having acceptable budget allocations. HUD Handbook 4265.1 on Multifamily Property Disposition (https://www.hudclips.handbooks/housing, accessed October 2025) says that HUD has certain requirements for condos. Individual units must meet all of the FHA's minimum property standards, and appraisals use specific condo forms (Fannie Mae Form 1073 and Freddie Mac Form 465). It's also important to think about the common areas. If the building has roof damage, foundation problems, a lot of deferred maintenance, or not enough reserves, it will affect your ability to get a loan even if your unit is in great shape. Before making an offer, check the FHA approval status in HUD's online database. Also, make sure your contract has a financing contingency that protects you if FHA won't approve the unit.
It depends on the type of repair and the lender's rules, but it is sometimes possible. HUD guidelines let you do some repairs through "escrow holdback" or "repair escrow," which is money that is set aside at closing to pay for repairs that need to be made after you buy the house. The escrow amount must be 1.5 times the estimated cost of repairs. For example, if repairs cost $2,000, the escrow must be $3,000. The lender or a third party keeps this money until you show proof that licensed contractors did the repairs correctly.
But HUD has strict rules about what kinds of repairs can be put off. Most of the time, health and safety problems can't wait until after closing. For example, lead paint hazards, missing handrails, major electrical problems, or anything else that makes the home unsafe right away must be fixed before closing. The property needs to be safe and livable from the start. Some repairs that can be put off are roof repairs that still work but need work, certain foundation repairs, exterior work that depends on the weather, or maintenance that doesn't pose an immediate safety risk. Because your lender is taking a risk by closing before the repairs are done, they have the final say. To reduce risk, many lenders want repairs done before closing. It's hard to live in a house while contractors are working on it. It's almost always better to make sellers do the necessary repairs before closing. This puts the responsibility on them and makes sure the work is done before you move in. Repair escrow only makes sense if the weather stops work from being finished or if the sellers don't have the money but will credit you at closing.
HUD put new Federal Flood Risk Management Standard rules into effect on January 1, 2025. In Special Flood Hazard Areas (SFHAs), which are places where there is a 1% or greater chance of flooding each year, new buildings must now have their lowest floor at least two feet above the base flood elevation. These areas are also known as "100-year flood zones." This is the "2-foot freeboard requirement." FEMA flood maps show the base flood elevation, which is the level of water that is expected during major floods. If the base flood elevation for your lot is 100 feet above sea level, the lowest floor of your new home must be at least 102 feet high to meet FHA standards.
Floods.org published an article on August 22, 2024, that said this affects FHA mortgages and low-rent public housing programs. You can read it at https://www.floods.org/news-views/from-the-directors-desk/three-things-to-know-about-new-hud-ffrms-rule/. HUD did this because homes that are at or just above base flood elevation are at a very high risk of damage from floods. HUD protects borrowers (especially first-time buyers who might not fully understand flood risk) and the FHA insurance fund by requiring extra elevation. This rule only applies to new buildings in SFHAs. Homes that are already built, even in flood zones, don't have to meet this new freeboard requirement. They just need to meet the FHA's minimum property standards and have flood insurance. If you're building or buying a new home in a flood zone, your builder must make sure that the home meets this requirement, or it won't be able to get FHA financing.
When sellers won't make repairs that are needed for an appraisal, you have a choice to make. First, know that sellers don't have to make repairs unless your purchase contract says they have to make sure the property meets FHA standards. Sellers can say no if they don't have that contract.
Here are your choices: First, agree to pay for the repairs yourself, either by paying for them up front during due diligence or by using repair escrow, which holds the money until closing. This means you have to pay for things that the seller should pay for, using money that could be used for a down payment or moving costs. Second, offer to pay the seller more for the repairs. For example, if the repairs cost $3,000, offer $3,000 more if they finish them. This works on a psychological level (sellers see a higher sale price), but only if the home is still worth the new, higher price. Third, don't go through with the deal. This hurts if you love the house, but it might be the best financial choice. The appraisal "follows the property" for 120 days, which means that other FHA buyers will have to make the same repairs. This gives you an edge because sellers may realize that refusing repairs will kill future deals as well. Fourth, talk to the seller again about the whole deal. They might not fix the roof, but they might lower the price by $8,000, which would let you make repairs after closing.
Advice: Don't let your feelings get in the way of buying a house. Think about the situation: is this a hot market where sellers have a lot of offers, or is it a slower market where they might have trouble finding another buyer? The size of the project matters: a $500 handrail or a $12,000 roof replacement. Talk to your loan officer and agent to get realistic advice on what is likely to happen and what is best for your situation.
Fact Checked