Trustpilot
Loading...
Loading...Loading...
Lately, I’ve been thinking about how many homeowners I've talked to who feel completely overwhelmed when trying to figure out how to access their equity. The textbook answer is, "compare your options and choose what fits your situation," but really, it's more about understanding what you're actually signing up for with each choice.
When you've built up equity in your home, you've got options. According to the Federal Reserve's 2024 Survey of Consumer Finances (accessed October 2025), the average homeowner who's owned their property for at least five years has approximately $200,000 in home equity. That's real money that can help with renovations, debt consolidation, education costs, or whatever matters to you and your family.
The two most common ways to tap into that equity are cash-out refinancing and home equity loans. But here's what nobody tells you upfront: these aren't just two different products, they're fundamentally different financial strategies with different risk profiles, cost structures, and long-term implications.
Think of it like this. A cash-out refinance is like selling your old car to buy a newer, bigger one. You're replacing what you have entirely. A home equity loan is like keeping your car but taking out a separate loan for a motorcycle. You've got both payments to manage now.
A cash-out refinance means you're replacing your existing mortgage with a completely new, larger loan. The new loan pays off your old mortgage, and you pocket the difference in cash.
Let's walk through a real scenario. Say your home is currently valued at $400,000, and you owe $150,000 on your existing mortgage. Here's the math:
According to CFPB guidelines (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, accessed October 2025), most conventional lenders require you to maintain at least 20% equity after the cash-out refinance. In this example, you're well above that threshold.
Here's what surprised me when I first started working in underwriting: closing costs on a cash-out refinance can run 2-6% of your new loan amount. On that $270,000 loan, you're potentially looking at:
Now, if your current mortgage rate is 4.5% and new rates are 7%, you need to calculate whether the cash you're getting is worth the higher interest rate over the life of the loan. Let me show you what I mean.
The monthly payment jumped by $1,038. Over 30 years, you'll pay $326,280 more in interest than you would have on your remaining original mortgage. That's a real cost, and it's why I always tell people: run the actual numbers for your situation.
From my experience working through hundreds of these scenarios, cash-out refinancing works best when:
At AmeriSave, we've worked with thousands of homeowners through the cash-out refinance process, and what I've noticed is that the most successful outcomes happen when people are using the money strategically: paying off high-interest debt, making value-adding home improvements, or covering significant one-time expenses.
A home equity loan is a separate, second mortgage that sits behind your first mortgage. You borrow against your equity, receive a lump sum of cash, and make fixed monthly payments at a fixed interest rate over a set term (typically 10-30 years).
Here's something that doesn't get explained enough: your home equity loan is in second position. What does that mean practically?
If something goes wrong and your home goes into foreclosure (I know, nobody wants to think about this, but stay with me), the first mortgage gets paid first from the sale proceeds. The second mortgage only gets paid if there's money left over. Because of this increased risk to the lender, home equity loans typically carry higher interest rates than first mortgages, usually 1-3 percentage points higher.
According to data from the Federal Housing Finance Agency (accessed October 2025), the average rate spread between first mortgages and second mortgages has ranged from 0.8% to 2.5% over the past decade, depending on market conditions and credit quality.
Let's use the same $400,000 home with a $150,000 existing mortgage.
Closing costs for home equity loans are considerably lower, typically $500-2,000 total, sometimes waived entirely if you meet certain conditions.
Here's what that home equity loan actually costs you over its life:
Compare this to adding $75,000 to a cash-out refinance at 7% over 30 years: you'd pay approximately $104,500 in interest on that $75,000 portion alone. The shorter term and separate structure of the home equity loan actually saves you about $50,000 in interest in this scenario, even with the higher rate.
This is what I mean when I say you have to run YOUR numbers. The "right" answer depends entirely on your existing mortgage rate, current market rates, how much you need, and how long you plan to stay in the home.
In my experience managing these projects, home equity loans work best when:
AmeriSave now offers home equity loans for primary and secondary residences, and what I've seen is that our most satisfied borrowers are those who viewed this as a strategic short-term financing tool, not a long-term debt solution.
Whether you choose a cash-out refinance or a home equity loan, you'll run into the same fundamental constraint: Loan-to-Value ratio, or LTV.
Your LTV is the total amount you're borrowing divided by your home's current value, expressed as a percentage. Here's the formula:
LTV = (Total Loan Amount ÷ Home Value) × 100
For a cash-out refinance, it's straightforward:
For a home equity loan, you calculate Combined Loan-to-Value (CLTV), which includes both mortgages:
According to guidelines from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac (accessed October 2025), here are the typical maximum LTV limits:
Here's something that often surprises people: your credit score affects not just whether you're approved, but your maximum LTV and your interest rate. Based on current lending standards (CFPB data, accessed October 2025):
This is why I always tell people: work on your credit score before you apply. A 40-point improvement can literally save you tens of thousands of dollars over the life of the loan.
Beyond LTV, lenders look closely at your Debt-to-Income ratio (DTI). This determines whether you can actually afford the new payment.
DTI = (Total Monthly Debt Payments ÷ Gross Monthly Income) × 100
Let's work through an example:
Current DTI: (1,560 ÷ 6,500) × 100 = 24%
Now let's see what happens with each option:
Most conventional lenders set maximum DTI at 43-45%, though some go to 50% with compensating factors. FHA allows up to 56.9% DTI in some cases. According to Fannie Mae guidelines (accessed October 2025), borrowers with DTI above 45% need excellent credit (typically 720+) and significant cash reserves.
Both options typically take 30-45 days from application to closing. Despite what some marketing materials suggest, the timelines are very similar for both options once you factor in all the steps, including the mandatory three-day right of rescission period after closing.
Here's where things get important, and I'm not a tax professional, so consult with one, but here's the general framework based on IRS guidelines (accessed October 2025):
The actual tax benefit depends on your tax bracket. But here's what I've learned from talking with clients: most people overestimate the tax benefit. According to Tax Policy Center data (accessed October 2025), only about 9% of taxpayers itemize deductions anymore since the standard deduction increased substantially. If you're not itemizing, the mortgage interest deduction doesn't help you at all.
Here's something I wish more people understood: closing costs create a break-even point. You need to stay in the home (or keep the loan) long enough for the benefits to exceed the upfront costs.
You're choosing between:
If you're planning to move in 3-4 years, the home equity loan is financially superior in this scenario, even though it has the higher rate.
According to the Mortgage Bankers Association's forecast (accessed October 2025), we're in an interesting period. Rates have stabilized after the turbulence of 2022-2024, but we're still well above the historic lows of 2020-2021.
What this means practically:
Here's what really matters: both cash-out refinancing and home equity loans give you access to your home equity, but they're fundamentally different tools designed for different situations. The best choice depends on your specific circumstances, not on which option is "better" in general.
Choose a cash-out refinance when you want to replace your current mortgage with a new loan, need a substantial amount of money, current interest rates are competitive with your existing rate, and you value having one simplified monthly payment.
Choose a home equity loan when you want to preserve an excellent existing mortgage rate, need a smaller or medium amount of cash, plan to pay back the money relatively quickly, might move within five years, or prefer keeping your home financing separated into distinct obligations.
Whatever you choose, make sure you're using the money strategically. The best uses are investments in your home that increase its value, consolidation of high-interest debt you're committed to not accumulating again, or major one-time expenses like education or medical bills.
At AmeriSave, we've helped thousands of homeowners navigate exactly this decision. We offer both cash-out refinancing and home equity loans for primary and secondary residences, and we're happy to walk through the specific calculations for your situation.
Remember: your home equity represents years of payments and property appreciation. Accessing it should be a thoughtful, strategic decision, not a quick fix for temporary cash flow problems. Take your time, ask questions, and make sure you fully understand what you're signing up for before you move forward.
Ready to explore your options? Visit AmeriSave.com to get started with a cash-out refinance or home equity loan application or call our team to discuss which option makes the most sense for your goals.
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. (2025). Home equity loans and lines of credit. Retrieved October 28, 2025, from https://www.consumerfinance.gov
Federal Housing Finance Agency. (2024). Mortgage interest rate data and trends. Retrieved October 28, 2025, from https://www.fhfa.gov
Federal Reserve. (2024). Survey of Consumer Finances. Retrieved October 28, 2025, from https://www.federalreserve.gov
Freddie Mac. (2025). Primary Mortgage Market Survey. Retrieved October 28, 2025, from https://www.freddiemac.com/pmms
Fannie Mae. (2025). Selling Guide: Cash-out refinance guidelines. Retrieved October 28, 2025, from https://www.fanniemae.com
https://www.hud.govU.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. (2025). FHA loan requirements and guidelines. Retrieved October 28, 2025, from
U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. (2025). VA cash-out refinance guidelines. Retrieved October 28, 2025, from https://www.va.gov
Urban Institute. (2024). Housing Finance Policy Center: Mortgage rates and homeowner behavior. Retrieved October 28, 2025, from https://www.urban.org
National Association of Realtors. (2024). Remodeling Impact Report. Retrieved October 28, 2025, from https://www.nar.realtor
Mortgage Bankers Association. (2025). Economic and mortgage rate forecast. Retrieved October 28, 2025, from https://www.mba.org
Internal Revenue Service. (2025). Publication 936: Home mortgage interest deduction. Retrieved October 28, 2025, from https://www.irs.gov
Tax Policy Center. (2024). Analysis of itemized deductions under current tax law. Retrieved October 28, 2025, from https://www.taxpolicycenter.org
Start by looking at your current mortgage rate compared to today's market rates. If your current rate is significantly lower than what you'd get with a cash-out refinance, a home equity loan usually makes more sense because it lets you keep that great rate on your first mortgage. Next, consider how much money you need. For larger amounts over $75,000, cash-out refinancing often has better economics despite higher closing costs, because the lower interest rate saves you money over time. Think about how long you plan to stay in the home too. If you might move within five years, the lower closing costs of a home equity loan become really important since you won't have time to recoup the higher upfront costs of refinancing. Finally, look at your monthly budget. Can you handle two mortgage payments, or would you prefer the simplicity of one combined payment? Your answers to these questions will point you in the right direction.
Your credit score significantly impacts both your ability to qualify, and the interest rate you'll pay if you do qualify. For conventional cash-out refinances, you typically need a minimum credit score of 620, though 660 or higher gives you access to better rates and terms. FHA cash-out refinances might accept scores as low as 580, but you'll need to meet other compensating factors like higher equity or lower debt-to-income ratios. Home equity loans generally require similar or slightly higher minimum scores, often around 640 to 680 depending on the lender and how much equity you have. The real impact comes in pricing, though. According to recent CFPB data, a borrower with a 760 credit score might get an interest rate a full one to one and a half percentage points lower than someone with a 640 score, which translates to hundreds of dollars per month on a large loan. If your credit needs work, spend a few months improving your score before applying. Pay down credit card balances below thirty percent of your limits, make sure all payments are current, and dispute any errors on your credit reports.
A home equity loan gives you a lump sum of money all at once, with fixed monthly payments at a fixed interest rate over a set term, just like your first mortgage works. You borrow $50,000, you get $50,000, and you start making payments immediately on the full amount. A HELOC is a home equity line of credit, which works more like a credit card secured by your home. You're approved for a maximum credit limit, but you only borrow and pay interest on what you actually use. HELOCs typically have a draw period of five to 10 years when you can borrow money as needed and make interest-only payments, followed by a repayment period of 10 to 20 years when you can't borrow anymore and must pay back the full balance with principal and interest. The interest rate on a HELOC is usually variable, meaning it can go up or down with market rates, unlike the fixed rate on a home equity loan. Which one is better depends on your needs. If you need all the money now for a specific project like a kitchen renovation, a home equity loan makes sense. If you need flexibility to borrow over time, maybe for ongoing home improvements or as an emergency fund, a HELOC might work better.
Both options will cause a small, temporary dip in your credit score, but the impact is usually modest and short-lived if you manage the loan responsibly. When you apply, the lender pulls your credit report, which creates a hard inquiry that might lower your score by a few points, typically three to five points. If you shop multiple lenders within a thirty-day window, those inquiries usually count as a single inquiry for scoring purposes, so don't worry about getting multiple quotes. The bigger temporary impact comes from the new loan itself, which lowers the average age of your credit accounts. If you've had your current mortgage for 15 years and you replace it with a brand-new loan through cash-out refinancing, that affects your credit history length. With a home equity loan, you're adding a new account rather than replacing an existing one, which also impacts your average account age but leaves your first mortgage's positive payment history intact. The good news is these effects are typically minor, maybe 10 to 20 points temporarily, and your score usually recovers within 3 to 6 months as you make on-time payments. The long-term impact actually tends to be positive if you use the money to pay off high-interest credit card debt, because that dramatically improves your credit utilization ratio.
Most lenders require you to keep at least 20% equity in your home after the cash-out refinance or home equity loan, which means you can typically borrow up to 80% of your home's value minus what you owe. Let me show you how this works with real numbers. If your home is worth $400,000, 80% is $320,000. If you currently owe $150,000 on your first mortgage, you could potentially borrow up to $170,000 total through a home equity loan while staying at the 80% threshold. For a cash-out refinance, you could take out a new loan for $320,000, pay off your $150,000 existing mortgage, and walk away with about $165,000 in cash after closing costs. Veterans with VA loan eligibility have a significant advantage here because VA cash-out refinances can go up to 100% of the home's value in some cases, meaning eligible veterans might not need to leave any equity in the home at all. Some conventional lenders will go to 85% loan-to-value for borrowers with excellent credit, typically above 740.
Cash-out refinancing involves all the same fees as getting your original mortgage, which typically run two to six percent of your new loan amount. On a $275,000 loan, expect $5,000 to $16,000 in closing costs. The biggest fees include the origination or underwriting fee, which is often 1-2% of the loan amount, the appraisal which runs $500-$800 dollars, title insurance and search fees ranging from $1,000 to $2,000, and recording fees. Many lenders let you roll these costs into your new loan amount, but that means you're financing them over 30 years and paying interest on them. Home equity loans have much lower closing costs, typically $500 to $2,000 total, and some lenders waive them entirely if you meet certain criteria like setting up automatic payments or maintaining a minimum balance. You might pay an application fee, appraisal or valuation fee, title search fee, and recording fees, but the individual amounts are smaller and there's usually no origination fee or it's much lower. The tradeoff is that home equity loans generally carry higher interest rates than cash-out refinances, typically one to three percentage points higher, because they're in second position behind your primary mortgage.
Yes, you can absolutely refinance a home equity loan or pay it off early, but you need to check your specific loan documents for prepayment penalties. Most home equity loans today don't have prepayment penalties, meaning you can pay extra toward the principal or pay the whole thing off whenever you want without any fees, but some lenders charge a penalty if you pay off the loan within the first two or three years. This penalty typically ranges from 1-3% of the loan balance, though it often decreases over time. If you're considering paying off your home equity loan early, run the math on whether that's your best use of extra money. If your home equity loan carries an 8% interest rate and you have credit card debt at 18% or car loans at 6%, paying off the highest-rate debt first usually makes the most mathematical sense. Refinancing your home equity loan might make sense if interest rates have dropped significantly since you took it out, if your credit score has improved enough to qualify for a better rate, or if you want to adjust the payment term.
Both options typically take 30 to 45 days from application to closing, though the actual timeline depends on several factors including how quickly you provide documentation, whether your appraisal comes in at value, and how backed up lenders are during busy seasons. Once you apply, the lender orders an appraisal or valuation, which usually happens within seven to 10 days. The appraiser visits your property or completes a desktop valuation, and the report comes back in about three to five business days. Meanwhile, you're gathering documentation for underwriting including pay stubs, tax returns, bank statements, and anything else the lender needs to verify your income, assets, and employment. Underwriting typically takes 10 to 15 days, though it can be faster or slower depending on the complexity of your situation. If everything checks out, you'll schedule a closing date. After closing, there's a mandatory 3-day right of rescission period for primary residence refinances and home equity loans, which is a cooling-off period where you can cancel the transaction if you change your mind. The lender can't disburse your funds until this three-day period ends. So realistically, you're looking at 33 to 48 days from application to having cash in hand.
Using either option for home improvements often makes sense because you're investing in your property, the interest may be tax-deductible if the improvements are substantial, and renovations typically increase your home's value. According to the National Association of Realtors 2024 Remodeling Impact Report accessed October 2025, certain home improvements recoup seventy to 90% of their cost in increased home value, making them genuine investments rather than just expenses. Kitchen renovations, bathroom updates, adding a deck or patio, replacing the roof, and upgrading to energy-efficient windows are among the improvements with the best returns. The question of cash-out refinance versus home equity loan for renovations comes down to the same factors we've discussed: your current mortgage rate compared to new rates, how much you need to borrow, and how long you plan to stay in the home. Many homeowners prefer home equity loans for renovations because they're borrowing a specific amount for a specific purpose, they get the money in a lump sum to pay contractors, and they know exactly what their payment will be over a fixed term. Make sure you borrow enough to complete the project. Running out of money mid-renovation is one of the worst situations homeowners face, so add a cushion of 10-15% for unexpected costs.
This depends entirely on the interest rates, the amount of debt, and whether you're comfortable securing the debt against your home. Cash-out refinances and home equity loans typically offer much lower interest rates than personal loans or credit cards because they're secured by your home, but that's also the risk: if you can't make the payments, you could lose your house. Personal loans are unsecured, so the lender can't take your home if you default, but you'll pay much higher interest rates, often 8 to 20% depending on your credit. If you have $25,000 in credit card debt at 18% interest and you can get a home equity loan at 8%, the savings are substantial. On $25,000, you're paying about $4,500 in interest annually on the credit cards versus $2,000 on the home equity loan, saving you $2,500 per year. Over five years, that's $12,500 in savings, minus the $1,000 or so in closing costs, for a net benefit of $11,500. But here's the critical question: why did you accumulate that credit card debt in the first place? If it was a one-time situation like medical bills or an emergency, consolidating with a home equity loan makes sense. If it's because you consistently overspend, moving that debt to your home equity doesn't solve the underlying problem.
Fact Checked